2am and I'm sobbing

I'm making my way they your stories. You are an excellent writer

My feels are crying, and it's from both chapters, not just this one.

You did GREAT. I love the idea of Sam trying to say "thank you" to Dean, and that was the best way to do it - and the most non-chick-flick moment ever. And then everything that Dean had written? I was crying before I hit the 4th line, so the fact that it took Sam all the way to the bottom before he cried? Amazing. And I'm soooo glad you did it when Sam got his soul back. When they truly were brothers again. Thank you thank you thank you!

gracious sakes... um...yeah...u've got me "hiccup crying"
tender and heartfelt...thank you

Wow! That was absolutely beautiful! I have tears running down my face... Thank you

Absolutely adore this so much. xD
Poor mans cinnamon toast made me laugh harder then I thought I would!

OMG! Sammy held out a lot longer than I did before crying. This was so beautiful. "I should've hugged you one last time" yep that's where I lost it. I can't constructively type the things I loved about this story. Just painfully brutally beautiful

Words cannot describe how perfect I find this.

I wish season six had been more like this, rather than having Sam return without his soul. I'm really missing the closeness between the brothers right now, but it's stories like yours that help make all the heartbreak bearable.

Thank you for this.

Somehow I missed this chapter the first time I read this story.
And, yes, lots of tears.
How I wish...

Thanks for sharing this.
TG

This is probably the tenth time I've read this and it still makes my eyes water...so beautifully done, so perfectly Sam and Dean. Highlights the best and worst of their relationship, all the things you wish they could say to each other but don't. "Sammy, I wish you were HERE" is just the perfect ending to Dean's list.

Spectacular job!

GAAaaahhH! MMM... I'm frickin blubbering here! This made me bawl, I'm seriously WEEPING! You should write a 3rd Chapter where Sam actually reads what Dean wrote!... I LOVED this! NEED MORE! PLEASE!

VERY SWEET AWESOME JOB!

I don't know what it was, but for some reason, Dean's list had me crying like a heartbroken school girl O.o

It was fantastic, and I appreciated the happy ending, even if it wasn't how I expected it to end.

Thank you :)

This was so sweet, I loved it. I liked the theory itself, and all of the things said. It was so heart warming. :3

Ok Clair is evioll. mekks this Bytchh cry.

:(

I loved this. I wish everyone that's lost a loved one had the chance to say the things they needed to say before they're gone.

Thank you for writing this.

*slinking off to dark corner to assume fetal position and cry*

Clair, I love this so much. Even though it's very sweet and chick flick moment inducing.

*smishes you tight*