| Reviews for The Marauders' Tale |
|---|
miniandminie chapter 43 . 7/3 Wow. I've been reading this story on and off, whenever I could find the time. I really couldn't find any mistakes. Everything was very nicely put together, and welly coagulated. My absolute favorite character is Remus Lupin, and you portrayed him very well, especially in the later chapters. I love seeing him as a vulnerable, weak, boy when he's young, turning into a mature man when he grows older, kind of bottling up his feelings, only to be opened by Tonks later in his life. You portrayed him very well, and you did an amazing job making Peter actually be a Marauder. I love the many ideas that this story was full of, the many pranks they pulled off. I do think that Mr. and Mrs. Potter were a little too 'perfect', and if I had to change one thing, I would have given the characters more flaws (i.e. Sirius not being able to stand up to the teachers every time, maybe someone else saving the day?) But I do appreciate the fact that they each had their own problems (James Lily, Sirius his family and all that, Peter his lack of love, and Remus his lycanthropy.) Overall, I really appreciate the fact that you gave us such a wonderful story that I just kept reverting back to. Thank you so much for your inspiration and amazing story! |
miniandminie chapter 44 . 6/5 THIS BOOK WAS AMAZING! I COMPLETELY LOVE THE MARAUDERS AND HOW YOU PERSONIFIED THEM! I've read lots of Marauder books but this was THE BEST by far! I LOVE IT |
girlfromkerteh chapter 9 . 3/18 James yanked her ponytail lol |
Carin chapter 44 . 1/25 So in 2020, you are not going to keep this story going, right? I loved the story! |
Prawn Flamingo chapter 42 . 1/23 I must say, I'm really impressed! So many chapters and new insights, good job, this is splendid! |
brushstrokes chapter 44 . 1/14 Recently rediscovered this series and was devastated to see one of my favourite series has all but disappeared. Full support to the author if this was their choice but will keep my fingers crossed that these stories are re-uploaded or somehow make their way back into my life. They are the best depiction of Harry with a living parent with all the ensuing changes I've ever come across. |
lisura chapter 2 . 7/6/2019 Oh, this Chapter hit me right in the feels.. |
Guest chapter 44 . 4/12/2019 I don't understand the purpose of keeping stories up if you've got no intent on updating them. |
wx4rmk chapter 44 . 4/11/2019 Not sure if you're still reading comments on this story, but I had to tell you how much I enjoyed reading this the past couple weeks. It seemed so natural and how I imagined the little Marauders'. I literally had to stop and remind myself several times that this was just fanfiction and not one of JK Rowling's works. Great job! I hope you'll eventually decide to continue to write about the rest of their years at Hogwarts. |
Hogwartsletters chapter 2 . 3/27/2019 It seems that the link for the stories also now doesn’t work. Someone is trying exepctionally hard for the NFL series to be removed off of the internet. If anyone has any contact with the author or knows somewhere where I could save the stories then that would be brilliant. I love them and I was half was through the 4th story. Please however do not post it publicly online and send me the link via PM (private message). I hope it wasn’t taken down due to copyright? I seems so odd that a story would just disappear and someone is trying really hard to keep it that way! Please let my know the reason if you do know! |
fangirl 9010 chapter 44 . 2/18/2019 Link for the not for anything series :) r/HarryandGinny/comments/9co65i/does_anyone_have_a_copy_of_not_for_anything/ |
fangirl 9010 chapter 1 . 2/8/2019 I’m looking for the not for anything series. If anyone can send me a link or anything to it please pm me :) |
Hogwartsletters chapter 1 . 12/29/2018 If anyone knows where to find the NFA stories, could they please pm me? I miss them a great deal and I don’t know why they have been taken down? |
Guest chapter 1 . 10/2/2018 Hi, I’m really missing you NFA stories right now, please can you repost them, just so people have time to save them or can anyone who had saved them, please please check out my accounts bio, Niamhpotter (I’ve reviewed before if you scroll down) I think it’s clear that Patient Rebel probably won’t be putting them up again so please email them to me! I’m missing them so so much I could honestly cry! |
Guest chapter 1 . 9/30/2018 Anyone know where I can read the NFA series? |