| Reviews for The Alchemy of Silver and Gold |
|---|
mochita chapter 17 . 5/25 Thank you for this story. I really liked the flow and theme if it. Your storytelling is very similar to the anime. My only critique on it is that i felt like the ending was rushed. It probably would’ve been better to divide the last chapter in 2 parts. I just think a little bit more story was needed to be told between Kenshin and Kaoru. All in all great story. |
Marquise de Nile chapter 17 . 10/12/2018 Thanks for the story, I really enjoyed it! I liked the changes you made for the AU premise, putting all the characters in Bakumatsu era, but staying close and true to their original stories, like with Megumi still making opium for Kanryu and Yahiko pickpocketing in the beginning. It was nice to see Aoshi as a capable leader that cares about his subordinates, even after the loss of his old comrades. I also enjoyed your take on the Battousai side of Kenshin, which I feel was pretty spot on. Kaoru was the heart of the story and I loved what you did with her, especially on the fighting side. Her fight with Soujiro and then destroying Shishio's sword were cool and badass moments. I'm still wondering who killed Kaoru's father, even though it doesn't matter to the story, it's just my curiosity. Btw, I love the idea of Soujiro staying with Kaoru and becoming her student, it just seems like a suitable and positive development for his character. Thanks again, I had a blast reading this story! |
Guest chapter 17 . 9/13/2018 This was an awesome story! So creative and well written! And thanks so much for finishing it - that‘s pretty rare actually! |
Cookie chapter 11 . 9/30/2017 For a while, I’ve been binging on your story and it’s just so amazing! One thing that bugs me with these types of fics though, not necessarily bad, is that Kaoru is so powered up with girl power and other training that now she is basically the ultimate strong swordsman-sorry, swordswoman and she does nothing wrong that isn’t seen as exclusive to her and makes her more endearing. Because a battle hardened samurai will fight and think “wow she’s pretty” and already lose the fight. I’m pretty sure he wouldn’t underestimate her and honestly, this is why I like Kenshin older than her. |
DaleksandTimeLordsandPearsOhMy chapter 17 . 2/28/2017 lovely read! |
Just a Blank Space chapter 17 . 1/17/2017 I really loved reading this fic! It was full of the things I love, and your writing style is lovely. I read it all in one go, so forgive me for not reviewing chapter by chapter. Thank you for sharing this story with us. 333 Loved to see Strong!Kaoru soooo much. It was a beautiful thing that you did making Hiko her godfather. _ |
misstomie chapter 17 . 4/10/2016 I really enjoyed reading this! You are a really great writer. Thank you for this! :) |
KazeYasumi chapter 17 . 1/12/2016 I LOVED this! I ended up reading "Hood" first, and I like this one even better! This is definitely the best "Battousai"/Kaoru interaction one I've ever read. :] It was a nice fresh take on a lot of the characters, and I loved all your innovations with the plot, while keeping everyone true to form. |
InTermsICanUnderstand chapter 8 . 9/9/2015 I always love reading their encounters! It's nice how you integrated some of the canon events into your story. It's shaping up really well! |
InTermsICanUnderstand chapter 1 . 9/9/2015 I love the way this chapter was written. So excited to read the rest! |
HermsP chapter 17 . 7/10/2015 Hello I just wanted to say how wonderful your fic is! I really loved the idea o Kaoru being pretty independent and powerful in her own way, I just loved it! |
Edowen chapter 17 . 5/1/2015 I really enjoyed reading this story. Thanks so much for writing it. |
Guest chapter 17 . 4/2/2015 Oooh this story is amazing, i like this more than the main series, i sooo want to see kaoru fighting using a real sword and skilled at that |
Guest chapter 15 . 4/2/2015 Kaoru's on par with soujiro! Amazing! |
Guest chapter 11 . 4/2/2015 I love kenshin and kaoru's sparring, she's so strong...oh i so love a strong kaoru |