this is the sorriest piece of shit i've ever had the unfortune of reading.

ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL! so well written you acually made me cry...though I am in an emotional state as I came back from ROTK .~ but thats not the point! ::claps fuuh on the back:: GOOD WORK _

*drools for story* It's good! You said it sucked and I didn't believe you and I don't believe you now either, ha! It's cute and, sure, it's not your best, but hey! it was your first fic, and for being your first fic it was REALLY good :), and I can tell you that your writing has improved a lot now _. Keep writing! It's an order :P!

great story!

You are such a good writer, it almost reminds me of Francesca Lia Block's (I'm not sure of the spelling) fairy tales. The words all go together like poetry. That was a really beautiful story.

This is not a bad chapter at all! You are a really good writer and this is a beautiful story.

* shy wave * Ummm...hi everybody. I never read slash, because I hadn't seen many well written ones and I'd always thought everything was beautiful and perfect, just with the friendships, but I have some friends on this site who read your story and said it was really good and even though I don't get into slash, I'd like this one. So, here I am and I really like this story so far (I'm getting ready for a lot of "I told you so"'s). It is very well written and sweet. I gotta go read the next chapter now!

That was the most beautiful kiss I have ever read about *sniffles* I don't let many stories get to me, but this is just too much for me to stay unmoved s.t.s.

I hope that wasn't the end though! Yikes... that was just... OMG... *controls herself* Go on! )

FUU, MY DARLING! MY LOVE! MY TRUE...MY uh...MY SOMEWHAT-BUT-NOT-REALLY ONE AND ONLY! MY SWEET POTATO PUFF OF PUMPKIN-Y GOODNESS! MY DREAMSICLE OF DUMPLINGS!

...that was THE best fic ending EVER. I. LOVE. YOU. *tackle/hugs you*

ahh make it go away *curls up on ground, rocking back and forth with fingers in ears and shut eyes* Maaake it goooo aaaway! *sniffles*

You write it very well and geez this is dark lol But I LOVE it.. it's in my list of favorite stories :)

Sunshine!

Oh my god! What are you doing to them? This had better not be the end! Is it going to get better? This is horrible! Oh not the story, just this chapter b/c it is so SAD! Please make it better! (puppy face) please please please?

YOU ARE SO LGKNALERAN AHHHH *dies*

OMG, that was totally unexpected! Scary even! Argh I hope this is not the end, I hope the real good-hearted loveable Sam comes back! :)

ahhhhf dlkanvla scary ;_; WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO SAMWISE?

and seriously, if you dont writer more, i'll slay you. dude. you can NOT leave vegolas stranded like this.

humph. am still prettiest member in fellowship. *flips hair sniffily and walks away*

AHH PRETTYFUL ;_; jfd;bs i like the whole Incoherant Frodo bit. VERY cool. *big gay thumbs up* mmmm...homosexual hobbit men...