My only critique of this is that Puck is ALWAYS the one that's "in the wrong" and has to apologize and work for her forgiveness and that Rachel is always the perfect one who can do no wrong and doesn't ever have to seek him out and work for his. I really wish it was a lot more equal.

I love your style of writing! This was certainly entertaining

Perfection! I really loved the evolution of Noah and Rachel's relationship throughout High school and beyond.

Awwww! Thanks for writing!

ok, so that was pretty much perfect. I loved the pacing, and how you showed them growing into each other. Loved how the dramatics were kept to a minimum. Great job.

This is the most fucking perfect Puckleberry fic, or really, any fic, that I've read in a long while, and I smiled and laughed and shed a few tears now and then. And, at some random points, I thought all of these deep thoughts and right now I think I want to marry you. Thank you so much for this perfect in character monster of a fic. There isn't one thing I disliked about it.

Enjoyed

Totally awesome - so sweet, this is my favorite pairing besides Loki/Darcy :) Heh.

I absolutely adored ever last word of this story! It was purely amazing and so well written.

Thank you for sharing this fantastic piece of work!

First of all I just need to apologise for that one line partial review. I was reading the story on my phone and stupidly decided to leave you a review there but I accidentally pressed the submit button and couldn't change it. So apologies for that!

This story is absolutely amazing in so many ways it hurts! I've been reading all the way through but I can't bring myself to read the final chapter (it's just on 3am here and I should really not have started reading this two hours ago but I couldn't stop.)

I'm in love with the way you've written this, the characters are truly portrayed in such an amazing manner, the writing is so beautiful (you've tugged at my heartstrings so many times!), the entire story flows so perfectly and you are a very talented writer!

There are so many amazing writers on here and I think you've just joined the ranks of one of my favourites! And I think I might start to stalk your other Puckleberry stories because this one is so freaking amazing!

Thank you for writing it and sharing it and I will be sure to leave you a review (probably not as long as this one or possibly longer haha) upon commencement (which will have to be tomorrow because I really am getting tired and should sleep just a little ).

Once again, excellent job :D

This has to be one of the m

This has to be one of the m

OH MY GOD! This story was perfect i mean so perfect... you just got their characters down pat and i just loved it. thank you for a wonderful story!

beautiful

wow jus epic babe

mel