| Reviews for What Do You Want From Me? |
|---|
comealongpond chapter 3 . 3/18/2010 Yeah, I like this a lot. Cool idea how you keep switching the time periods. I'm excited to see what happens. |
comealongpond chapter 2 . 3/18/2010 This story is really good so far. Do Mark and Roger still live in the same loft after NINETEEN YEARS? Wow. Also, I respect you for making Mimi's real name Lucia and not Maria like most stories seem to do. |
JeNeParlentPasVraimentFrancais chapter 1 . 3/13/2010 Crap. I'm lousy. I though you had only one review- you have *eleven*. Whoops. So sorry about that (that meaning mentioning "your second review being negative"). Let's pretend I wrote "Your twelfth review being negative", okay? Sorry! |
JeNeParlentPasVraimentFrancais chapter 2 . 3/13/2010 Mm. Well. It's okay. But um... I can see Mimi *maybe* living the nine months. Definitely not *nineteen* more *years*. Neither would Roger. Or Collins. Or miraculously-alive Angel. No way. Also, fics like this are so cliche it makes my stomach hurt. So is the twin thing. And the "yay we had kids but they're negative!" thing. *And* the "Mimi is such a great loving devoted mother" thing. (If anything, I'd think Roger would want to keep the kids and she'd want to get rid of them). I really really hate that your second review be so negative, but a lot of people are going to take one look at this and run away. Maybe, if you try reallyreallyreally hard, you won't be cliche, but with so many gaps in logic (like, um, Mimi being *alive*?) it's going to be difficult for you. Oh, and as you're writing this, please remember that since you jumped nineteen years Mimi is 39, Roger and everyone else in their forties. I know you mentioned it, but still. So please don't write them in a way that makes them sound like 20-something year olds (i.e., Mimi should not be a stripper or a dancer or wear miniskirts, Roger shouldn't wear black nailpolish or eyeliner). Again, I'm sorry for being so harsh, but pregnancy fics/Mimi-Roger-have-kids-but-Mimi-leaves-him-so-and-so-years-later-Roger-comes-back-and-they-fall-in-love fics are so, so, so overdone. I know, because I wrote a pregnancy one, and looking back on it, it was utter crap (NOT THAT YOUR FIC IS). Also, I know that Mimi is dying in your fic, so that makes it "different", but I'm confused to why AIDS suddenly caught up with her yet she managed to *live for nineteen years*. And work on your spelling/grammar as well. Always comb through your piece before posting- spell-check doesn't get everything. Also, Maureen and Joanne cannot be legally married, seeing as NY doesn't allow gay marriage. One last thing- if you don't believe how overdone this is, I can prove it to you with some links. If you get really mad, I'm so so so sorry, because I've gotten negative reviews and started crying, and I *don't* want to do that to you. I just want you to be aware of all the cliches, because you need to know how difficult pulling off this fic is going to be. I'd be happy to beta for you, if you like, and I am so, so, *so* sorry for being so negative. I'm sure you're an excellent writer, but... yeah. Message me back if you like. :) I'm not actually a heartless bitch, I promise, and you can feel free to check out my stuff to help along your decision. |
MusicalIncline chapter 2 . 3/12/2010 This story is coming along quite nicely! I love the names you gave to Mimi's kids! |
HeavyDrugsOrGroupHugs chapter 2 . 3/11/2010 I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO SAID BESPECKLED ANYMORE! You don't know how happy that makes me. I am utterly captivated by this fic and I can't wait for the next chapter. You write with such intelligence. Bravo. |
Danielle chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 Ok, you are like so banging for this first chapter i'm like on the edge of my seat, please dont give up on this story its soo good. |
maria chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 ok i like seriously need you to post another chapter. AWESOMME start :) |
Cameron chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 Most def. continue it. I'll be disappointed if you dont. |
Linnaea chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 So far, so good. wonderfull first chap. Update soon :) |
Sarah chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 i need to know what happens next, please update. |
Kierstin chapter 1 . 1/10/2010 Please update soon. |
Kierstin chapter 1 . 1/2/2010 So far, so good :) Please update soon please :) |
Dino-SOAR chapter 1 . 1/2/2010 this is good. (: definitely continue it. |
MusicalIncline chapter 1 . 12/29/2009 Ooh, drama! This story seems like it has some serious potential so far. As for the lack of RENT fandom for the past year, you've captured the personalities of the characters really well. Keep up the great writing! |