Ok so this is what I think it isn't a cullen who killed tanya. Why you ask well when you put the last mystery pov you worded the killers statment like this"At least Cullen Manor was one hell of a place to be stuck for the evening." Meaning the person isn't at or doesn't live at Cullen Manor or isn't to familure but familure enough . Unless it is a Cullen whom doesn't live they yet knows the layout enough. But this statment is waht makes me thing that. I wouldn't think it was Jasper because he doen't (if you are using the southern jasper) use woeds like whore and such he woul normally put it a lighter or nicer way. I dont see it are her lover charlie he seems off because if it was him she wouldn't have said I knew you wouldn't be able to resist me to much longer. I think it could be Em but would that be easy since he conveniently went to 'tal' to his brother and it just couldn't wait. It could have been Edward. Yet it could have been a female (Im not sure) it could have been any of them . It could have been bella since she would have been to cullen manor because of her relastionship with Edward but she might not live there. It could have been (if it isn't a cullen or swan) Riley, Mike,Laurant,Jacob,james,felix,demitri,ciaus,aro,a nd males it could have been jane , leah,angela,ben chaney. Im really not sure but it is a very great story and I wish for you to update it. You havent since 2009 when the second twilight came meaning james and lurant were dead . So that cancles out. Im really not sure but I love the story so pleas pleas update it.

Emmett

I think Bella did it!

So we are definitely looking for a guy. I personally think it's Carlisle- at the vry least someone whose family was affected by Tanya. Maybe someone cheated? But now i'm pretty sure it's none of the Cullens since they talked about the mansion as if thy didn't live there. Maybe the butler has some secret motive?

:D

stumbled upon this story today and I just have to say, I love a good mystery. Clue is my all time favorite movie and I've been looking for a story like this one for a while. Okay, so mystery POV (killer)- I'm going a whim and saying either Bella or Henderson. Because, everybody knows, the butler did it. lol

Holly

I'm still betting on Esme. Maybe Carlisle. Family protection & all that. I know Esme is a woman & Tanta was strutting & shit. But Tanya doesn't strike me as disctiminatory

Em's the secret lover. Or maybe Edward since Em wanted to talk to Edward. Maybe Emmett knew. Who killed her? Esme.

Go Charlie. I'm pretty sure I've never read a ff with Charlie fucking.

Ugh! Tanya. I'm curious who the fuck buddy is. Carlisle & Edward seem like the obvious choices. So I'm going with one of the girls or Jasper.

hey cool idea for a story ]

LOVED THIS CHAPTER. UPDATE SOON!

I like this! I have no idea who the killer is but I can't wait to find out who it is!

Rhonda

I think it was Edward... That is unless Jasper is there? Is he? This is great fun...

i have no clue, but the name Ben Dover is friggin hilarious [bend over] hahaha

yikes... this is awesome, it's like clue... tanya was killed in the library with the carving knife by _

i can't wait to read ch. 4!