Brilliant simply brilliant... AAA my poor heart

It was good af

I come back to read this story every few months.
And I cry equally hard every time.

That last line...just killed my heart.

In a good way

Wonderful.

I actually started crying over this. This was just amazing. I know it's just a one-shot, but I really truly loved it.

Oh Rudy! How cute was that? Very beautiful job... I could see you put a lot of effort into it. :) This was wonderful, I felt like Death really was narrating next to me... (Hmm... that kind of sounded creepy!) Keep up the awesomeness... :) :)

These aren't tears.

Okay you caught me. This is adorable and something I could see Rudy doing. Though I think he would've teased Liesel for getting old. Idk I can see it happening though.

Wonderful. I especially loved Death's musings.

I. Loved. This. I can't believe this was your first story. Everyone was so in-character! And the writing was beautiful. Great job.

That was beyond description. It was too beautifully written to explain, but yet I shall still try. Tears welled up in my eyes. I couldn't help smiling at the end though. A small chuckle even escaped my pudgy mouth. The fact that the story caused me to feel like I was reading an extra epilogue chapter flabbergasted me. As stories do not usually give me such satisfaction. Perfection in its most beautiful description. No other way for me to have enjoyed it this much. For that I thank you. For giving me the feeling of worthiness. That Rudy and Liesel could still have the happy ending that they deserve. Rudy's stubbornness was perfectly portrayed and you went back to one of my all time favorite book scenes. I finally feel at peace with this story, and in return I have nothing to give you except an description of my emotions. I loved it beyond love. You have true talent and I would love to hear more from you. (I'm never good at goodbyes) I think I am done reading book thief fanfictions though, as I don't want anything to ruin this last moment. This last extra chapter that was never posted. Forever I will remember it, and that I vouchsafe you. Thank you again.

I really Need to not read Book Thief Fanfic for the rest of the night I keep stumbling on some great ones and I'm starting to tear up.

a lovely story. thanks for sharing

Oh my... This is too perfect. Thank you...
I'm so glad Rudy got his kiss. I'm off to get a tissue, because that's just how pathetic I am.

Oh that was so sweet :) I absolutely loved this finally Rudy got his happy ending

I live this. The real ending was so sad but this made up for it.