This story is really nice and u should complete it...please...please...please...will be waiting for ur update...please do it soon...

I'm glad I guessed that it was between Rebecca or Julian who killed Peyton :) Great story hope you update soon

It's not Lucas. It can't be Lucas. I totally esclude Brooke & Lucas.
Nathan had the motive which is revenge but he would have done it sooner. Only Haley is left, given that Peyton "hated" her but Haley would never kill anyone. I think none of these four killed Peyton. Maybe it was an accident and one of the children did it or Julian - maybe Peyton left him after the confession. Hahah so many possibilites but it's neither Brooke nor Lucas.

I refuse to believe Lucas would harm Peyton.

Not my Peyton :(

I think Brooke, Nathan & Haley are protecting either Lucas or Peyton for Keith and Rebecca sake. One parent is death and they don't want the other to be arrest for murderer.

Everything seems to show that Haley might be the victim. Brooke hate her for not attending the funeral & apparently she did something to Rebecca but the more I think of it the moment I think the victim is either Peyton or Lucas I'm 100% sure.

This is a nightmare. One of Peyton, Haley or Lucas is death? They are my favourite characters. I was praying the victim was Brooke or Nathan. I love them both but the other three are my favourite :(

Well Peyton clearly "hate" Haley & Nathan "hate" Peyton.
Mouth seems friends with everyone. There seem to be hostility between Lucas/Haley, Haley/Nathan, Brooke/Peyton & Nathan/Brooke. Really really intrigued. I'm curious about the who the victim is though. My theory is that maybe "the victim" tried to hurt one of them, one of them pulled the trigger in self-defence and they all decided to keep it a secret.

I know it's been two years since you updated this, so I'm guessing this story is dead. That's a complete shame because I read this story in the span of a few hours. I planned on only reading the first chapter and then go on with my day but I was completely 100% hooked. Everything is amazing and suspenseful and I love how when I think I have things figured out, BAM, another plot twist! I can't believe it was Julian..but then him being a doctor and saving Beckah? I don't get it haha. Anyway..I really hope you do update this eventually. Also you mentioned Salt being filmed in your hometown..would that happen to be Albany? I'm from near there too! So cool that you were in the movie!

You have to keep writing for us to find out ;) Please do! I know it's been a long time, but would be really awesome..

I hope you update this. It's really good.

OMG! this i a AMAZING story (: cant not wait till u update again! plezzz do it sooon!

i've just read all 21 chapters of your fanfic and i absolutely love it! it's one of the best OTH fanfics on here and i love the murder mystery and suspense that you've added to it. i find it heartbreaking that keith and beckah will grow up without their mother but i really hope that lucas will be fine so at least they'll have him. it's great how the 4 friends decided to stick up for beckah. (even though it was julian who killed peyton! argh!)
i can't wait till the next chapter! i really hope that you update soon- this fanfic has me hooked now! :)
bonboni
~X~

awesome story dying to read next chapter