Reviews for Who's To Say?
SavvySpirit chapter 70 . 6/19
Are you planning to continue?!
moonyblueviolet chapter 70 . 2/6
i'm really loving this story! my favorite bits are the fluff between lily and james, and i'm really enjoying reading them get...intimate. i really hope sirius and marlene get together eventually, and a little request is that you write more about remus and mary, cause i'm loving their dynamics too. and i really liked that slytherin girl (heather something), so i hope to get to see more of her. i know you haven't updated in almost a year, but this fic has been going for ten years, so i think (and hope) it's gonna keep going. and again, LOVING the story!
Stargaryen190101 chapter 3 . 5/21/2019
Well, so far, this IS a very good fic, and really, I think that it will grow on me. The author has depicted the confusion and conflicts of all the characters in a very good way, and I hope that they'll keep it up. I also think that they should do some factual changes in the fic, to be compliant with the info provided by JK Rowling, mostly the names of James's Parents. I know many people don't have a problem with that, but, I think it would make reading more enjoyable. Don't take this as a flamer. And for the language, English is not my first language, so if the tone of the message seems to be disconcerting, then I am sorry.
abbilowery chapter 70 . 4/24/2019
I'm in LOVE with this story it's honestly so good! You're such a great writer and the characters are not easily angry and dramatic as other fics, they are like real people. I think I'm probably gonna reread this story over and over, it's just so good!
Adeuh chapter 69 . 3/29/2019
Omg where has this fic been all my life? I’m completely hooked! Such great characterization, a little drama but not overly done as some Jily fics tend to do it. And tons is Sirius antics. It’s perfect, and well written too! Thanks a lot for this, hoping you continue this!
UnicornHazel chapter 54 . 3/2/2019
Sirius as Dumbledore is probably the best thing I've ever read
annmariek25 chapter 29 . 2/16/2019
?
treyjily chapter 68 . 1/2/2019
I just found this story and have been reading for about the past week non stop. Even staying up until 4am then waking up at 10am to continue reading it! I love your story and I genuinely hope you complete it. James and Lily are perfect in this and I love how you have written them. I can’t wait to read more!
Son of Whitebeard chapter 68 . 12/27/2018
OOH CROUCH ON PATROL
Youtoumii chapter 67 . 11/29/2018
Hey :) I read all 67 chapters in two weeks and oh god what a ride! I'm grateful that you're able to update once in a while even though you're very busy. I'm eagerly waiting for the next chapter
Son of Whitebeard chapter 67 . 10/26/2018
fun party
lilyofthelion chapter 66 . 9/8/2018
This chapter was absolutely lovely! Can’t wait for the next one.
Annunminuialiel chapter 65 . 8/20/2018
I’m glad you are continuing this story! I’ve loved reading it and look forward to more chapters! ️
Annunminuialiel chapter 29 . 8/16/2018
I love this story so much I’m losing sleep reading late into the night. You have a magnificent plot going and the characters are really well written and realistic.
lilyofthelion chapter 65 . 8/10/2018
I loved this new chapter and can’t wait for the next one! I do feel though like I am missing some dialogue between James and Lily? You write it so well, so I’ll be hoping for more in the next chapter.
Lily and James meeting each other’s parents was written so well I felt nervous along with them! Keep writing! As always, I love your work!
315 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »