| Reviews for Separate Council |
|---|
VasquezLives chapter 1 . 12/19/2019 A neat in-between moment, well written! I don't see a lot of interaction between these two, it was done well! |
BakerStreetIsLastRefugeOfHope chapter 1 . 4/11/2012 A great story. Very well written. |
yllom21 chapter 1 . 10/1/2005 Yeah, an Elf-Lord would have to much power. Nice little fic! |
Cassandra30 chapter 1 . 9/18/2003 Excellent Story! Very well thought out and well written. |
Siora chapter 1 . 7/14/2003 Very nice. I liked it! |
Kasifya chapter 1 . 8/19/2002 (beats self over the head) I can't believe it. I was sure i had reviewed this long long ago when I first read this. but NOOO.. i find out I haven't. This story is so good! it deserves millions of reviews and so i am reviewing to say, awesome fantastic wonderful story. You are the best writer on this site! |
Lisseyelen aka Lady V chapter 1 . 5/5/2002 You know...I find that a lot of people don't know what the "Halfelven" in Elrond's name is for. It doesn't mean he's a Half-Elf, oho no. It stands for something in elvish. *cocks head* It's in the Silmarillion. Which I don't have handy at the moment...so I'll have to trust my extremly leaky memory. I think it means "Star Band" or "Star Crown" or summat like that. Other than that...I really can't wait for you to continue this. The only problem I spotted was the "Glorfindel lingered for a while, then left to tend to his horse, which was winded after the near escape from the hands of the Ringwraiths." See, the Council takes place several days after the Ringwraiths. So, of course, Glorfindel's horse would have certainly caught his breath by now. Unless there was another encounter with them or it's a very out-of-shape horse or whatever. But that's the only thing wrong, I promise! OMG I LOVE HOW YOU USED GLORFINDEL INSTEAD OF ARWEN! He's the one who should really get all the credit in the movie, but nooooo! There *had* to be a "feminin presense." *snort* I mean, sure, haveing that is okay in a movie...but not when it totally messes up the story plot of the book the movie is after! And really...I'm offended that they chose Liv Tyler to represent us. Arwen doesn't have any lines in the book, and her name is mentioned only twice! And then there's the fact the she overshadows LEGOLAS who is one of the FELLOWSHIP! I mean...COME ON! SHE GETS TWICE AS MANY LINES AS HE DOES AND SO MANY MORE PEOPLE CALL HER ARWEN AND NOT "THAT HOT ELF" AND SHE'S JUST SO- *ahem* Whoops, got a bit carried away there. ANYwho... I look forward to the next chapter, if there is one. But if there isn't: Great job! |
TreeHugger chapter 1 . 4/6/2002 Beautiful. Your writing is truly wonderful. Your readers are the ones who are blessed. Elenath sila erin le! [Star shine on you!] |
Bloodthirsty chapter 1 . 2/13/2002 Awww! That was kinda sweet! It's nice, no wait- REALLY nice to see an Elrond and Legolas fic thats not slash! This is really cool! It's going into my favs list for sure! :D Tata for now! It's nice to see your still among the living though! |
Fred chapter 1 . 2/10/2002 Hey Ann this is really good! Great job with the characterization, you're really coming along from back in the days when...ah we won't mention those, eh? The horible recollections at your vast unfinished pile of stories. I like this better-short and sweet, yay! Happy writing! ~Fred |
Mehri chapter 1 . 1/30/2002 OH MY GOODNESS! THAT IS SOOO GOOD! I MEAN REALLY! it looks like you have read the books. That's good! In the movie they changed it around do that the members of the fellowship choose to come, instead of being chosen by Elrond. I REALLY LIKE IT! could you review my stories sometime? -archy |
Pass the Porn Tea chapter 1 . 1/27/2002 When i clicked on this fic i was not expecting a work so glorious! I was merely expecting another dull fiction written by another of the thousands of Legolas fans, but this fiction is most certainly not dull. This fiction was beautiful, thank-you for writing it ;) |
Maelwaedd chapter 1 . 1/27/2002 Honestly, this is the best written Legolas fic that I've found yet. Congrats on that... the world needs less fluffy shite. Thanks. |
Arwen4 chapter 1 . 1/26/2002 Well done, Rinoa. I like it! It gives a different point of view to Legolas's involvment with the Fellowship, and I am glad that Elrond was able to help him. Your writing is very true to Tolkien, as is the way that you KEPT Glorfindel in his proper place. That is one of my major gripes about the movie. It wasn't Arwen who went to find the five, it was Glorfindel. Well done! |
Poo7667676 chapter 1 . 1/9/2002 _excellently_ written. It's not often I see good Legolas fics over here in . Not often I see fics that doesn't involve him checking Aragorn out, as well. o_O Anyway, as I said, this is one of the best fics I've read. Kudos to you! |