It does make sense for Sam to he engrossed in his research but i don't blame Dean for wanting to have a Thanksgiving with him. It's sad Sam let it pass but I'm glad he realized and made it up to him.

It does make sense for Dean to not be in the mood with all that had happened at that point. I loved how Sam wanted it and was able to get Dean to agree with it even though it didn't get to happen because of Sam's vision. I did love how they did still get some pie and that it was John's favorite, which was very fitting.

I think you handled this really well. I loved how Dean was there for Sam without pushing too much and being near for him and I'm glad he got him out for Thanksgiving. I also loved Sam's thoughts and seeing his process. It was sad but I loved how even though he loved and missed Jess he could feel that coming home feeling with Dean. I think you did their thoughts and such really well.

This was so sad. I think you did a great job with depicting Dean's thoughts and feelings. It really fit into him and showed so much of what you see later. I did love that both Dean and Sam were looking at the stars.

This was another good one at explaining the seperation between Dean and Sam and how he was trying to keep going. I think he was happy with Jess but I think even if they had gotten married it still wouldn't be enough. I loved the different memories and you handled it all.

I loved that you did both John and Dean's thoughts regarding everything. I t hink you did a wonderful job showing the complexity of emotions that were going on. I felt so bad for them and I loved that John did that for Dean.

This was really good. It was sad because Sam was feeling the loss so much of everything. I t hink you did a great job at showing the feelings Sam was having regarding everything.

Poor Dean having to be in the hospital for that. I do love that Dean had gotten them a chance to be at one place for a while. I also loved how Sam cane up with a way for Dean to have Thanksgiving.

This chapter was really good. It's sad that both Sam and Dean are not really sure they belive John when he says that they will have Thanksgiving together but I'm so glad that they did. I thought you did a wonderful job showing John and who he is, it's hard to find good depictions. I think you showed the relationship between all three of them really well. Great chapter!

I really loved this one. I like that you showed the tension between Sam and John and how hard it is for Dean being in the middle. I loved how Dean was in support of John and yet at the same time making sure Sam was comforted and being there with him. I loved that you got in John's point of view here and why it was understandable as to why it needed to get done and what drives him. I think you captured John really well which isn't always easy to do.

The part when John tells them about going for a Thanksgiving dinner and him fully aware of how they both feel and are thinking was really sad. I did love that they did go and had a great time together.

I imagine it would be hard for them to see John hurt. I did like how Dean handled it and I loved that John told them to go and eat and that he knew what day it was. I loved that Dean shared his memories of Mary with Sam and that Sam saved that piece if pie.

I had no idea they had those types of flavors although I shouldn't really be surprised. I liked how Dean went out if his way to get that for Sam so he could still have Thanksgiving Dinner with his throat.

It would be understandable that Dean would feel frustrated about it. I loved how Sam explained why it is and his heartfelt statement and of course bringing him in with pie.

This was so good. I loved how Dean made sure that they could have a Thanksgiving all because Sam really wanted one. The way they came up with a meal was good. I loved Sam's reaction when it was all placed out and how he loved it because it was their Thanksgiving dinner. It was sad John couldn't be there but not surprising that Sam was okay simply because Dean was going to be there. And I loved how Dean was able to get the pie and that Sam decided he would feed the cats for Dean. This was so good and I loved the love between the brothers in here.

This was heartbreaking to read. I felt so bad for them. I liked how it was from John's perspective and how seeing how his family was resolved him to finding out about what happened to Mary.