Awesome story idea. While on one hand Sam suddenly becoming an only child on Reaper made more of a story as certain truths about the family came to light, having this was extremely enjoyable. Kyle was a regular kid, I liked the subversion of the coddled younger sibling to the Oliver's coddling of Sam. Ow for Kyle, but if he knew the truth of his parents' guilt it would make more sense for him. :C I also liked for how little Sam was here, gestures like him so awkward with the dummy and then glaring at it after he captured the soul was like seeing an episode before my eyes.

Totally adding to favorites!

Third paragraph - oh so true. We never see Kyle anymore. Bit of a shame, especially since they could use him in a scenario like this. That would be so awesome.

Just like this fic is. Great job!

P.S. You have siblings? The interactions are too real for you not to have one.

Interesting idea for a story. We never do hear anything from Sam's brother. This totally seems like a realistic scenario in the actual TV show and I like how you did it. The brotherly interactions between those two is hilarious. Keep up the good work

brilliant. I love it.