another great story. i really do love your writing. i especially liked patty looking down on paige and penny thinking that patty wasnt at the grave but all around. nice touches to it :)

Heartbreaking and gorgeous. I love how you write about the bonds between mothers and daughters stretching through several generations of Halliwells (even past life Piper mourning past life Leo!), and that it begins and ends with Penny & Patty.

Absolutely beautifully done.

Good Lord Katie. This story makes me want to cry, and the last line came pretty close to making me do just that. A new favorite.

I think this is my favorite story so far of everything you've written. You captured so much emotion in only a few sentences for each story, got your point across and moved on. I love writers that can convey so much with so little. In the Charmed World that loss always seemed to be one of the most difficult things the girls had to bear, this is a perfect example of that. You're such a talented author, I hope to keep reading more!

Megan

i loved this story, very sweet.

I love it. Very sweet and sad.

*favourites*

Loved this story...thanks!

Sweet and touching. Your writing makes my day.

That was a great story, it was the first time I ever felt sorry for Grams.

One word: Fantastic!

Wow, that so great! your a brilliant writer :)