Very cute, and love the ending.

This is AMAZING! Please make a sequel! What will Sam and Dean do now? Maybe they could find some mermaids to mate with. They'll have to steer clear of sharks and people who want to catch them. I really wanna know what happens to them!

loved it!

I really like this. This is now my favorite:)

Oh I loved this! But it made me sad... Because our boys are free and at peace here, something they deserve so so much but never get in the series :( I don't understand the people who like when the boys hurt, I just want them to be happy...
Really lovely idea and very nicely written, thank you :) Now I'm wondering about what they'll eat (hope Dean won't miss his burgers too much!) and what if someone sees them or they get caught by a fishnet? A sequel wouldn't be amiss!

Aw...

freakin perfect!i love the fact that they have diffrent colored scales... but arent some fish both male and female? ...just saying.

OMG, that was beautiful, and sad at the same time. Im tearing up. Yup, here they come.*starts bawling* that– it solved a lot of problems BUT WHAT ABOUT CAS?! AND THE WAY YOU ENDED IT, *sniffs* It was like a goodbye. This- this- talent. It takes a LOT to get me to cry without music, and you did it. *goes over to cry in a corner*

oh my god is soooooo cute! :3
I Love it!

I like.

This is great! I love it.

Not bad.

Never thought there could actually be a really good story where Dean or Sam gets turned into a merman... Fantastic job proving me wrong! :D I like how it ended this way, with them leaving the hunting life forever instead of losing everything trying to save the world.

Broadway doesnt have Dean and Sam. XD so sweet. I liked it!x3

This was absolutely amazing and adorable! Mer-Dean... uhhh fangirl drool coming down the side of my mouth right now. And then mer-Sam, oh my gosh your brilliant! This is like one of my favorite SPN fanfics ever now and helps because as a kid The Little Mermaid was one of my favorite Disney movies. I'm surprised that Supernatural hasn't done a mermaid episode yet, it would be so cool if they did and one of the boys got turned into a mermaid! ;)