I love this. Very beautiful and I love how there really is no dialouge gives an extra somethin' ;)

Aw I LOVE IT! :)

GAH! that was so sweet!

RYRO rules. yeah!

Sweet one shot!

Thanks!

Aw! That was so sweet! Thank you!

Really, it was awesome. Beautifully written, -I loved your descriptions of every little detail of each birthday . This is, oh my! you got me speechless. Seriously.

*takes deep breath*

Okay. No one has ever written something for me and on top of that, it is great. I was in sore need of sweet romance, all of this mixed with a superb job of entwining all of Rogue's birthday with each memories ... and, in the middle of everything, my fave pyromaniac, John.

Love ya! *hugs*

It's sweet and cute. I like it. Pyro does seem like the best birthday present ever.

lovely

A good idea and lovely writing to do it justice _

I like how you don't mention the guy by name (sorry if you have actually dropped so many hints about who it is that you'd have to be a mental not to know who it was) because whilst I was reading it, I was half thinking about Rogue!Logan, and then Rogue!Pyro and even Rogue!Remy and because you didn't mention exactly who you were thinking about, it made all my pairings win _

Yeah, that toally made sense _

Whatever, loved it.

i love it! it was beautiful. not sweet or sad but just right to make me say "aw" after and while i was reading it! good work on this nice little oneshot!

I'm a bit slow, at the end was Pyro righ? Hehe you'll have to ignore my stupidity. )