I love this story. I've read it a few times on The Tomb, but thought I'd come by here so that I could review it. I miss the brotherhood and the amazing complex and interesting characters you created. Your series is so perfectly put together that sometimes I reread just so I can stop by Jim's farm and hang out for a while.

I loved this.. Awww so good!

Well, that was an awesome ride! Thanks so much for Christmas story.

AWWWWW.

I'd have given to see a scene with John and Caleb... :3

Ah welllll.

I'm not sure if I every gave a review for this fic but I thought I should. I read it for the first time a while ago when I first found your AU. I just re-read it again to make sure that I wasn't screwing anything up while writing my tag to Wendigo.

This is SUCH a great story. It's so well put together and I love all the different POV's. The addition of Esme gives such a great new dimension. Anyway, I just wanted to show my love for this story.

*hugs*

Thank God everything turned out ok, 'cause there for awhile I was lookin for my torch and pitchfork.

Merde! If your gonna make a girl cry like a baby in the first paragraph YOU NEED TO WARN HER FIRST! I was emotionally unprepared for this chapter. *pulls a Sammy-style b*tchface*

Aww, we finally reached the much needed fluff. 8)

This was an awesome chapter, and summed everything up nicely. Joshua and Ian's scene was a great way to break up the comfort and humour of the other light-hearted scenes. Added some great drama and mystery there... Very foreboding!

So overall, this was a very angsty story (I went through a few tissues!), but with some lovely fluff - an incredible read. 8)

- Coolest Badguy EVER

Woah... Long chapter, that. 8P

So much drama, angst, mystery, action and suspense wrapped into one. And one heck of a cliffhanger - man, am I glad the next chapter's there!

Poor Joshua got hit on the head. 8 I do like Josh, so I felt quite sorry for him with all the rough treatment he got. Least they've found Caleb. 8)

Very exciting chapter! Loved it muchly.

- Coolest Badguy EVER

Oohh, the angst! My poor heart! *gets tissue*

You know what? I was reading this, and getting sad and emotional, what with the morbid gathering of the Brotherhood and the bittersweet memories, but you wanna know what pushed me over the edge? The straw on the camel's back?

...Atticus.

I knew he was old, but I couldn't remember when he died, and then they say he's gone! I definitely needed the tissues for that one!

Very angsty chapter, I'm needing some fluff, here!

- Coolest Badguy EVER

OH NO! CALEB'S DEAD!

...Thank God I know it's not true. ;)

Nonetheless, this was a very emotional chapter (my sleeve's a little wet, I must admit), particularly the last part with Dean remaining silent ever since he got the news. It's reminiscent of after his mother died, and tugs at the heart string hardert than ever.

Very sad start to the story - now to go find Caleb. 8)

- Coolest Badguy EVER

Loved this, particularly the first chapter. I really liked the 'flashback' to the earlier christmas.

And I can't help but like Joshua, and him knocking out Ian in the cave was awesome :)

“I didn’t see any fat guy in a red suit using a sleigh to drag my ass out of that cave. That was all you, Deuce…and your elf Sammy. And if I haven’t made some kind of drug-induced girly scene out of it already; I really appreciate it. You guys saved my life.”

I loved this qoute!

Dean handed him a package of peanut M & M's. "Dad bought them for me on the ride over. You can have them. Mrs. Morris says I know how to share."

Caleb smiled. "You're not too bad Deuce."

Dean scrunched up his face. "My Dad calls me Ace." He corrected the teenager.

Reaves swung his legs over, and stood up. He tussled Dean's hair. "You're Deuce to me."

\

I loved this part:)

love it so far!