Reviews for Dumbledore's Biggest Mistake
devilpest chapter 10 . 8/11/2019
I wish you would come back and finish this story
Gin110881 chapter 6 . 7/17/2019
Harry had a lot of interesting and sometimes curious tests to pass, and now there are two Harry's in the past. I'm quite curious what the two of them will do. I can't imagine the Harry from the future is going to walk around freely.
Gin110881 chapter 5 . 7/17/2019
Oh, the train ride at the start of Harry's 3rd year. It was Harry who more or less told Ron to shoo Ginny away because he wanted to talk to Ron and Hermione in private.

You often let Ginny look like a twelve-year-old, and not like the fiery girl we know from OotP and HBP. That's a bit confusing.

I'm not sure yet how Harry's time travel is going to work. With all the things discussed, I don't think his older self will try to get to know a much younger Ginny. So, I guess we'll see a young Harry with knowledge of the future. We will see.

While I'm often a wee bit confused by the behaviour of some of the characters, especially Harry and Ginny, but I really like the concept and the basic idea that the deadline for a prophecy was missed.
Gin110881 chapter 3 . 7/17/2019
They were lucky, according to the second prophecy they had no chance to defeat the Death Eaters when they attacked Hogwarts.

The price is Harry's life? As if the Horcrux is gone, too?

Hmm, they are discussing the option that Harry will loose his life without knowing the deatils of what Hermione found out...and they even agree that it's worth Harry's life without knowing details, and even without asking Harry about his opinion.
Intriguing Cliffie. What happened to send them to the past? Did Merlin help?

(Sorry, I somehow confused the chapters for the reviews)
Gin110881 chapter 4 . 7/17/2019
Ah, at the end of the last chapter I thought they were already gone to the past, lol.
Aw, Ginny is on a 'Harry Potter guilty trip'.
Good thing that the adults explained to Harry what decisions they made for him. Harry takes it surprisingly calm that almost everyone readily accepted that he has to die to get rid of Voldemort.
Gin110881 chapter 2 . 7/16/2019
Oh, Harry chickens out and asks Dumbledore to inform everyone else about the new situation.
It's bad enough that Ginny has to overhear Harry to get the news. But it's certainly better as if she'd been told about the prophecy by Dumbledore instead of Harry. It's a matter of trusting each other.
They know that Voldemort knows the prophecy, but only protect Harry, not Ginny. That's careless.

Hmm, several weeks have passed, and Harry never talked to Ginny. It seems they aren't as good friends anymore as they were last summer when they could talk about everything, as Harry'd told Hermione.
I hope Harry will become a wee bit more active instead of hiding behind Dumbledore's back. It's okay to accept help, but does he really intend to let others do all the work?

I loved the story so far, and I'm looking forward to finding out where you're going with it.
Gin110881 chapter 1 . 7/16/2019
What an intriguing idea. I love it already. I wonder who DDD, DED, and TED is.
Guest chapter 10 . 10/28/2015
Hey! This story is awesome!. Hope it continues on an won't get abandoned...
nayin17 chapter 8 . 6/29/2015
Love the idea of Ginny being in Harry's year
nayin17 chapter 7 . 6/29/2015
Like what Harry wrote on the wall
Mentathial chapter 10 . 1/6/2015
wow..update soon!
Bronze chapter 10 . 1/1/2015
Getting tutored by none other then Bast on mastering his feline forms is almost unbelievable! But then again the three Fates seem to've taken a liking to him. I'm glad you set out how and what Harry invested with the twins. Most other authors merely say that Harry's a silent third partner in their joke shop business. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad Harry did. I just always wanted to know what the contract basically said and how much he invested. I'm also very glad that Harry got to meet his family even though they're dead. Regardless of being Lilly's sister that woman was never a true aunt to Harry.
Bronze chapter 9 . 1/1/2015
Yeah, working a forge will build muscle. After all, have you ever seen a weak blacksmith? It's good to see Harry having some time with his Godfather. Now if some witch or wizard were to zap the Dursley's into being decent human being Harry would have had a true childhood.
Bronze chapter 8 . 1/1/2015
Wow, I wonder what Harry did to Malfoy SR besides mildly stunning him? I'm willing to bet he got something good out of that Death Eater. Yeah he freed Dobby but with the chance to make Malfoy SR spill something valuable, I can't see this Harry passing it up.
Bronze chapter 7 . 1/1/2015
One soul fragment down but how many to go is the question.
122 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »