It’s so nice! You’d written this very good. These short stories are those that I often dreamed of. They’re very cool.

Sickening. This is not discipline. Spanking a child with a paddle NAKED is child abuse, nothing else.

Awesome, adorable, and relatable to many im sure! Remus, Sirius, and Harry are all lovable characters, and i wish them adopting and protecting him throughout the series was like this.
To all the people calling you sick: calm down. Its called discipline - dont pull the rape, abuse, or whatever card. Grow up. If you dont want to read more, L.E.A.V.E.
As for the author, keep it up. Youre very creative.

Ur Sick... Spanking? Naked? How fucked in the head are you? Please seek help. Sicko.

right... I'm sorry but this must be the worst story that I ever came across. your writing style is fine, but the content is outrageous and sickening. you must really take joy in writing about humiliating a kid after every 2-3 paragraphs.

right... I'm sorry but this must be the worst story that I ever came across. your writing style is fine, but the content is outrageous and sickening.

WTF. Lupin is a dick and he has no right to spank a student, no matter what he did. Making Harry take off his pants and shorts is already a sexual assault. Lupin has no business near kids' bare butts.

I really like Remus's reaction and his way of dealing with things. I also like how he always says the he loves Harry and hugs him every time h punishes him; it shows how he actually cares for Harry and thinks of him as a son. I wish my freaking parents were like this. But I got it better than others anyways, one of my friends is punished as the following: she has to strip down and stand naked infront of her brothers for at least for an hour and sometimes it would last for seven, they would then have fun with her like pinching and squeezing her breasts until they are red, they would also take turns spanking her and drowsing her with ice cold wate, they would also take pics of her this way and show them at school. And she has seven older brothers, only one feels pity for her. So yeah that pretty much does NOT sum. Three of them R*PED her.

BTW: this is my real name

loved this story. its on my top 3

Oh my god you're really a pervert! All you write is about spanking, did you get too many spankings and they messed up with your head? I suggest a doctor cos you're not normal, actually you scare me, the way you indulge in this abusive crap is revolting

Love it! :)

Harry would be taller than Lupin if Lupin is sitting...do you realize how short he'd have to be to be the same height as someone sitting in a chair? He'd be the height of a third or fourth grader.

The spanking in this chapter is way too harsh. not to mention at this point in the story, Harry has no idea that Lupin even knew his parents or that he knew him as a baby. As a teacher, Lupin has no right to punish Harry in this fashion. Not reading any further.

Well I really like this author. I think I liked once more with feeling a tad better but I loved this to. I really got a kick out of Sirius getting a good one. But what is Lupin teaching now in this book?

Sorry not reading anymore. One Lupin is NOT Harry's guardian so he doesn't have permission to spank any child.