I absolutely loved your story despite its heartbreaking is so well-written and the characters are vexactly as the good job, thank you for uploading it!:)

THis is beautiful and heartbreaking! Wonderful writing!

No! Christine, go back to him!

Lol. That was SO good!

OMG that was heartbreaking and so sad, but I loved it. I'm sat here bawling my eyes out. I love you Erik!

Ooh... ooh, angst... yowch... are you going to follow up on this? Add more? Oh, this could be so good, I can just imagine it... will you? I could be your beta, if you need one. Please? *puppy dog eyes* I love a good story...

- Adi

This is the best novel based Phantom phan phic I've ever read! I'm reading more of your stories!

Excellent! This is a very VERY EXCELLENT story. You catured the essense of Leroux and combined it with your own style, making a very beautiful story, five stars, brilliant!

Aw! That is so sad! But you wrote it beautifully!

Wow.

Really REALLY wow. I cant think of anything to criticize on. For the most part your characters were in character, and the plot was cute without taking away from the original ending. Very nicely done, I'm glad I stumbled across this little gem _

I really love this,(switches to french in head, but can't spell it) because, well... I don't know but it's really good. (Back to thinking in English) It's cool that you've made it sound like the book, with word choice and style. That would be difficult for me to do.

Oh my lord! You wright just like Gaston Leroux, in an awesome way. It wasn't fluffy or contrived like some phan-fics are. Great job!

This was beautifully written! I could not find fault with it.

~OceansAway

How sweet. I liked it. To the faves it goes!

- LtSA (LovetheScottishAngel)

So sad! Great job!

Very well written. You have portrayed Erik's love for Christine with great understanding and sympathy. His emotion comes through loud and clear.