This one made me cry. . .

That was very accurate. Not just on a historical level (though it was well researched), but on an emotional level, too. Even though I wasn't alive on December 9, 1980 to hear about. . . the event when it happened, I reacted similarly when I found out.

How powerful. Sirius' shattered hope...wow. I wish I had the words to tell you how much I enjoyed this, but I can't really explain it.
What a flawless job.

So original, cute and perfect. I love it

As a Beatles fan myself, what can I do but love this fic'?
Beautiful written, so many emotions in so little words...

I love this.

3 just, yes. I'm so happy you've included the marauders and the Beatles together. I love marauder era, and the Beatles are my favourite band - it's so lovely the way you've made Sirius emotional and actually show his feelings. And just, wow, it's beautiful. The Yoko Ono/ Lily reference was good too- it just sort of showed that Sirius felt that they were the Beatles and they would get back together. Thanks for writing this! It's great

cute fanfic...sum facts were wrong, but what the hell.I am a Beatlemaniac, so naturally im picky bout anything FANFIC!

This story really moved me. As I was reading I got shivers, and thats when I know a story is good, no brilliant. Eleanor Rigby was playing in my head all the way through and as I was reading I found myself longing for warm summer afternoons. I loved the flash backs and how they cared so much, because I have always imagined Sirius and Remus as caring people even if sirius hid it well when he was younger. Also, I have to say that you made the story very realistic (I can't realy tell if the facts are right because I wasn't born either, but it seemed realistic to me.) So basicaly, thanks for the awesome story and the originality of it:)

Squeakykid.

Sweet and pretty and sad, but more sweet than anything else :)

~Mademise Morte

this is so bloody sad

Owww... I really like this fic. It's was beautiful, seriously. I like the SiriusxRemus couple. And the feeling of the beatles as well. I like the guitar in bars and happy afternoons at Hogwarts. Anyway, I liked how the story unfolds.

So, very well done.

With love, Rose:]

awww, remus is so understanding. i love the way he sees the Beatles.

Aww, sad. Such a shame some idiot was stupid enough to kill one of the greatest artists in the history of music.

That is the cutest and saddest thing I have seen today. :)

I love Remus caring after Sirius, and I love Sirius insisting that the Beatles will reunite.