| Reviews for Casting Moonshadows |
|---|
   ihoio chapter 86 . 7/5 This story really brought the characters alive for me, like it actually made me contemplate how sad their deaths were at such a young age which no other fanfiction and definitely not the actual books made me do. I guess they'd always seemed distant as the story focused on the next generation but you really made them come alive for me so I just wanted to say thank you for that. |
| ihoio chapter 73 . 7/4 Okay, so this chapter was really vivid and, I don't really know how to describe it other than that, I just really sort of felt what was going on, so yeah I just wanted to say that it was really well written. |
| ihoio chapter 60 . 7/4 Okay, I've never really done reviews before so this is not going to be very informative at all. Basically I just wanted to say that I really love the final section of this chapter (though all of it is very good), it's just so sweet and it makes sense and it's cute and is just a really nice snippet of their relationship that shows where they are really well. |
| Guest chapter 86 . 7/1 Hey! Im only at part 67 but I really love the story! I wanted to now if you have an instagram account and if I can post the summary and first chapter on instagram to make a little advertisement? Thanks! |
| Guest chapter 54 . 7/1 Ish, I thought it was a comment not a 'review'. I don't know if they're the same thing, I'm new on this platform. My point is, I wasn't critizing the story, I was making a comment on James's attitude (cause I know, that would be the attitude that canon James would have) |
| Guest chapter 54 . 7/1 I mean... Remus is right. I don't know if saying the truth makes you a bad friend but James doesn't have the right to control Lily. And I know he's not gonna control her (let's be honest, Lily wouldn't let him), but still, I don't think he has the 'right' to knoe everything about her. I think I didn't explain myself that well |
| Maddy chapter 1 . 6/30 i really like the words chosen and how they were used. it made it very dramatic. nice job! |
| Guest chapter 86 . 6/30 THIS ENTIRE STORY WAS AMAZING. SIMPLY AMAZING. THANK YOU TO WHOEVER WROTE THIS. |
| UngrstefulCupcak chapter 86 . 6/29 This is the absolute BEST thing I’ve ever read. I NEVER read this much of one fic but I read all this because it was just that good. Thx for making this :) |
| Renesha chapter 86 . 6/19 Oh My God. I absolutely love your fic Moonsign! I swear I've never been more crestfallen than when I saw the gif hasn't been updated since 2017. Please give us more updates! |
| toolazy chapter 38 . 6/19 I'm too lazy to log into my account, but I just wanted to show how much I love this fic! I'm feeling sooo many emotionsjfae[roidhfv[onjlm |
| Cailin chapter 86 . 6/18 Are you going to make more chapters? It's ok if you don't I know that I'm reading this in 2020 but this was the best thing I have ever read in my life and I would most likely read this again |
| Danika chapter 2 . 6/15 Can I use some ideas from this in my fanfic if I credit you. third reread! |
| whofan1212 chapter 86 . 6/15 please please PLEASE if you have any thoughts about finishing this please do. i love your versions of the characters and itd be brilliant to see it through to the end |
| Guest chapter 1 . 6/10 I don't know if you ever read these anymore but holy shit I read this fic in high school over and over again, it's been 5 years since I first read this and I still come back to it, I think about it, this is a masterpiece, one of the best things I have ever read |
