| Reviews for Message in a Bottle |
|---|
vach.tm chapter 20 . 6/21 Oh my God! I hope you come back soon to finish this fic. It's really good! |
Duchess67 chapter 4 . 6/5 Okay, your author's note at the top of this chapter let's me know the fic gets even more unbelievable in regards to abuse. So I guess I should stop reading? Seriously though, how can we possibly believe that Harry survived on so little food up to this point? And don't say magic, because that don't cut it. If Harry gets no actual meals in his life, he would be dead. End of story. Look, I get it. You want to portray Harry as terribly abused. But abusers really aren't THAT stupid. They make sure their victim gets enough food to be able to function and always make sure there are no VISIBLE signs of abuse and neglect. Harry would be an emaciated scarecrow, AT BEST, and steps would be taken to remove him from that environment. Obliviations or not. Dumbles would be there DAILY trying to get Harry back with the Dursleys! Make it more believable and I'll gladly come back and read. |
Duchess67 chapter 3 . 6/5 I'm having a difficult time believing the abuse was this bad. If it had been, Harry wouldn't have survived to this age. Honey, you need to make it believable. This isn't. |
Ironmonger chapter 20 . 5/25 really, really would like to see more of this story! I think it is the best of the "future knowledge" genre I have read. Please write more. |
Eldersprig chapter 18 . 2/13 1) best use of an actually magical curse used against someone too much of treating magic as a different technology in both canon and fanfiction 2) boggart excellent! |
hellina2000 chapter 1 . 10/15/2019 I wish you wouldn’t bash your writing - it’s really quite good. Just finished Demon and your concept of the schools of magic was fascinating and well described. Looking forward to this one (even tho I see it’s incomplete). Thank you for your work! |
Ghidorah15 chapter 2 . 10/11/2019 To the cowardly anon who last reviewed this, if that BS can even be called a review: Up yours. |
babiluv22 chapter 19 . 8/31/2019 I wish you would write more |
Quinn chapter 20 . 8/12/2019 Thank you, this story is really good. Please continue writing as I would love to see how it finishes Thanks! |
Mionefan chapter 20 . 6/28/2019 Ahh! A 4 year cliffy! Not an abandoned story, I hope. |
IndigoBirds chapter 14 . 5/28/2019 Knowing this isn't finished- and May Never be finished, is sad. It's really a true gem in the ff realm. |
Sextant chapter 20 . 4/21/2019 I hope you get back to this someday. |
Calmzone1 chapter 20 . 3/7/2019 What a fascinating story. Well done. If anyone didn’t like it...sucks to be them. |
kent-jensen chapter 20 . 2/17/2019 plz finish or re-write |
Mattnunescavalheiro chapter 20 . 1/23/2019 It's a shame there's no more story after this. The writing, prose, and dialogue were amazing . And this story is extremely underrated . It's creative and doesnt fall into exposition heavy tropes a lot of fanfics fall into . Or at least it has heavy exposition done in a way that fits the story . I hope you come back to this some day . Til then , we'll be here rooting for you :) |