| Reviews for Spirits of Another Sort |
|---|
Obi's Second Cousin chapter 8 . 9/25/2010 Cue dramatic music! So it seems Puck's playing has consequences- good thing Snape caught on! Wonder if Dumbledore will... |
Obi's Second Cousin chapter 7 . 9/25/2010 *giggles madly* Best chapter yet- I love that you brought the centaurs back in! And Robin messing with the map! |
Obi's Second Cousin chapter 6 . 9/23/2010 *grins* Robin's afraid of flying? Oh dear XD And an excellent ploy there by Jack to get her on a broom. |
Obi's Second Cousin chapter 5 . 9/23/2010 Hmm... Lupin as a potential threat and Dobby as an acutally comprehensible, verbally adept little fae... I like these interpretations! You rock. Have I mentioned that lately? |
Cinnamon Cigarettes chapter 1 . 10/6/2008 I think I'm really going to enjoy this. The fact that it includes Puck is lovely. And Puck being female just makes sense to me. You're going to make me obsess over this fic, aren't you? I can already tell I'm going to get addicted. It's actually kind of nice to see a Harry Potter fic that is adding in some different characters. |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 7 . 10/9/2007 I am so so so SO sorry it's taken me this long to review. Life has not been liking me in many and varied a way. I like this chapter. It's nice to see Robin and Jack interacting both with the wizards and with Oberon, and good to see that Robin isn't so powerful that she can't succumb to friendship. As usual, I love Robin and Jack's conversations with one another, and I like the idea that Jack's dislike of Malfoy is steadily becoming more and more obvious. The last moment between Robin and Oberon was sweet, and you handled the encounter with the centaurs very well, right down to them being more than slightly annoying. So, overall, very nicely written, as usual, although I keep finding myself appreciating the Faerie interaction more than the mortal interaction, so you might want to focus on that a bit more. It still seems weird watching Robin be such an interloper, but you're handling it well and carefully, which is the right way to do this. Sorry for not reviewing sooner. Freya Sacksen. |
mrmistoffelees chapter 7 . 9/27/2007 Excellant story! I can't wait to read more. |
Honebar chapter 7 . 9/24/2007 Oh my I have to say I do like the rewrite much more. _ I had wondered how Puck was going to keep her eye on the young dragon but with the fun pook's help it runs much much smoothly.. hmm me thinks Dobby be hidein something.. that I do. |
Deljuj chapter 7 . 9/10/2007 nice i like puck but will she ever meet Fred or george? |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 6 . 7/21/2007 Oh, that was good. That was very, very good. I love Puck at the end. She's so...lovely in her scariness. I think it's wonderful that you're finally bringing out Puck's nasty side. It reminds me of a quote from Terry Pratchett I like to think of whenever Robin gets too nice. 'Elves are wonderful. They provoke wonder. Elves are marvellous. They cause marvels. Elves are fantastic. They create fantasies. Elves are glamorous. They project glamour. Elves are enchanting. They weave enchantment. Elves are terrific. They beget terror. ... Nobody ever said Elves are nice. Elves are bad.' I look forward to more evil Puck-ness. |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 5 . 6/3/2007 Lovely, as per usual. I'm not sure the depiction of the elves is quite in-character or, at least, not what I'd expect. They don't seem to be treating Puck with much liking. Respect, yeah, sure, but they really don't seem comfortable around her. I love the idea of Lupin figuring out what they are on the full moon. And good on ya for keeping one of my favorite lines from the book 'pity sugar renders it completely useless.' Ah, yes. Poor Harry. I can't wait until he gets out of the castle. What on earth will Puck do? |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 4 . 1/8/2007 Nicely done, Miss Nicniven! I had been wondering how you were going to deal with the boggart, and that was well done! I love the backstory - that Puck refused to turn aside from Oberon. And the conversation with her and Jack was nicely written and paced. Trevor the parrot. Squark. Squark. |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 3 . 1/3/2007 I love the idea that wizards are so frustrating that Jack and Puck resort to fags and alcohol. Alcoholic fae among wizards...it's hilarious. I like how you wrote Puck's reaction to Trelawney, and how she darkly comments on it to Jack. I can HEAR her when she deadpans her comment on divination. I apologize for not reviewing earlier but I've been avoiding as it seems that all social activity is suddenly taking place on devART, which is highly unfair. Anyway, very well written, as always. |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 2 . 11/29/2006 Ah, yes, the Destruction Of Snape's Demeanor returns! I look forward to it! I'm very much looking forward to Defence Against the Dark Arts...I can imagine Puck's reaction to a werewolf in the position...either very hilarious or very disquieting. I do look forward to seeing how Slytherin affects Jack, and if Puck gains even a slight conscience (ha!) from the Gryffindors. And if Harry found out her true nature... Yes, I am very much enjoying this. Continue, please! If I do my best to get more AKON chapters in, you must continue with the SAS... ...That's a fun acronym. I'm gonna keep using it. |
fivethingsunmixed chapter 1 . 11/29/2006 I think I really concerned my father. When you started talking about the Glamour I sat up, half-cackled and clapped my hands in glee. You're really going to make this FUN aren't you? I think you were actually smart to put this into the Harry Potter section. It's also kind of nice to see Glamour about the place again, especially in shape-shifting (as that was what Glamour was renowned for doing, back in the day). I LOVE the idea of Dumbledore being genuinely threatening to the Fae, and the half-romance between everyone's favorite trickster and Titania's evil helped is just priceless. I also love the accent he gets when he acts 'mortal' and the idea of Robin approving of the Weasley twins. I am now going to read the next chapter, and hopefully feel yet more glee. Bwahaha! Keep on rockin'. |