| Reviews for Second Thoughts |
|---|
Fan chapter 1 . 1/28 I was reading the last section, and it felt like you were leading to Tom Riddle... and then Percy of all people! Wonderfully done! |
long live marshmallows chapter 1 . 7/19/2014 Hm, that's interesting. I like this monologue. |
Bushwah chapter 1 . 5/22/2013 So Ron has a chat with the Sorting Hat? Sounds legit. Good job. |
wckd19 chapter 1 . 12/26/2012 So true...Percy probably would have done better in Hufflepuff, but I think it all came down to his family being Gryffindors for generations. He would have stood out, well more, in his family. I think it makes sense since he worked hard for his achievements. A nice fic and it was great to view the Sorting Hats thoughts. |
creativesm75 chapter 1 . 5/7/2012 nice |
White Lotus19 chapter 1 . 2/19/2012 That was amazing. It must have taken a lot of thought to make that Hat's monologue, especially the part about the founders. As for Percy being in Hufflepuff, it would probably have been better for him because he would have developed in a different way. I think that's what your trying to get at in the story. |
The Terrible Jester chapter 1 . 9/23/2011 great story! |
Tamira chapter 1 . 5/31/2009 wow, that was a long monologue the hat talked there... Well, I know Ron aparently was there, too and also asked questions and all... When was it? your story, that is... somewhen probably between book four and six... mayybe more like in book five? I don't know and I am curious! Percy a Hufflepuff? I am not so sure there... it might have worked, but wouldn't Ravenclaw have been better for him? what's you thoughts about why Hufflepuff? (I like Hufflepuff and I like Percy... but in my mind both does not seem to go well together...) Well, I'l just have a look for that story you mentioned in the A/N... Bye, Tam |
Random Projects chapter 1 . 4/30/2007 Woo! Go Hat! It was cool, refreshing and interesting to read the story from the Sorting Hat's perspective. Very original! It's true though... Percy really could belong anywhere... He's courageous (well, kinda), ambitious (duh), smart (more duh) and hard-working (but perhaps not meek/humble, like most Hufflepuffs are). But anyway... I think while it might improve Percy's haughty demeanor, it might actually destroy him much quicker (If the rest of my family was sorted into one house, and I to another 'wimpy' (Hufflepuff), 'know-it-all' (Ravenclaw) or 'evil' (Slytherin) house, my family members are likely to give me grief about it. We all know how nasty the twins and Ron could be to Percy.) So I'm not entirely sure that the results would have been a 100% positive if Percy was in another house. But it's just me. Great fic! Hope you write more Percy or Ron stuff! |
kikos ai chapter 1 . 8/7/2006 Very nice! I like how you really took the time to think out the Sorting Hat and make him a real character. Good job! |
Infestation of Vitality chapter 1 . 7/8/2006 Brilliant. Lovely fic. It goes without saying that I enjoyed it very much. Percy probably would have done better in Hufflepuff. They probably would have loved him. |
RavingBabbit chapter 1 . 6/16/2006 It would've served Percy right. \ I wonder how much of the gossip went over Won-Won's (with his emotional range of teaspoons) head. Best (and only) Hatfic I've read. |
Spice of Life chapter 1 . 6/10/2006 That was a really good fic! I really, really liked that one-very original idea you had there, and I like the point you expressed. I sound like a critic in training though, don't it? So I'll just go back to being myself and say this-awesome, awesome fic-it's going on my favorites list! |
Pandora of Ithilien chapter 1 . 6/7/2006 i knew it was ron when you said family tradition... percy in hufflepuff? hmm... nice fic, by the way. |
Andrea Rimsky chapter 1 . 6/7/2006 Hee! Nice surprise ending. |