I like it. I agree that in Season Eight, the sisters drifted apart. I hope that you show them reconnecting again. That would be great.

this story was awesome. i absolutely loved how Paige finally called Phoebe out on how selfish she had been lately. it was about time someone did. i still can't believe that she had the nerve to move out right after Piper lost Leo.

It's so sad, yet so beautifully written.

Katie, I adore how you bring forth the feelings of the girl.

I wish I had sisters to share this with.

That made me cry. Update asap i want to read more of this.

You captured each of the sisters perfectly. I do feel bad for Piper. Things always go wrong for her and her sisters (specially Phoebe) don't seem to care while Piper feeds them and gives them a place to stay. I'm glad Paige called Phoebe a bitch cause thats what she is. I'm still hoping the day will come that they would do it on the show. But I know Brad loves Alyssa so much that her character will be treated special.

u have to write more even if Piper, Paige, and Phoebe split it would make a good chapter then put some drama in it but u have to write more even if it's short just write.

What a beautiful and insightful one shot! Wonderful characterization :)

I loved this. I liked how it was from 3 points of view. The Piper one was my favourite, because in my opinion she is the one who has been the most hard done by. First Leo was taken from her and then Phoebe moved out, leaving her alone. And then Paige and Henry married and now she is all alone, just left with her children. Her piece showed so much emotion for the loss of her husband and then the love for her precious baby, the only remenant of Leo.

The Freebie storyline of wanting a child is really getting to me. I get that she wants one, but she has become so selfish about it that it bugs me. I liked how you mentioned the 'I' list...I liked that.

The Paige one I liked as it showed how she had always wanted a sister and then all of a sudden she has 2 and she has to cope with living with them etc. I liked that.

Overall I loved the one-shot. You are such a good write, I loved your Piper/Leo one shot. :)

I don't watch the show anymore, but I felt this disconection back on Season 7 (which was the season I stopped watching).

It was a great insight on the girls lives and I believe you did it pretty well.

I don't know how Paige's life is like right now, but Piper and Phoebe were portrayed perfectly.

I love your style of writing, its captivating. I do however have one big criticism. You've said this is a one-shot. WHY? This is so excellent that it deserves at LEAST another chapter! Please consider writing more :)

i loved it. i'm adding it to my favourites. you did really well even though i had no clue to anything coz i havent seen season eight, only heard about it... this story makes me sad that i dont have any siblings... and the line, 'Mommy, can I have a sister for Christmas? I really want a sister.' hit a chord with me for it is a line i have used many times some years ago, and though i'm 18 now, i still secretly wish for sisters (even a brother or two)... so i like, but at the same time hate, this story (but in the good way - if there is such a thing)i'm done rambling now :)

I completly argee with this whole story. The sisters are drifting apart and Billie somehow gets to have a sisterly relationship when the main characters in the show are loosing theirs. Thank you for this story. Kern needs to read it.