records lost... I don't care if it's a cop out that's both genius and hilarious!

This is by far the BEST LotR fanfiction I have ever read. That's impressive consedering I've read just about all of them.

Well done

How old is the author?
12?

So good! Made me laugh so much and it's so refreshing to get out of Legomances and The Fellowship's journey, that tends to get a little old at times. So good job so far.

Beautiful

I liked it, it was unique and it was different from those that I have read. Although, one thing that I did not like was how the mother was also in the story. I thought that the mother was not really needed because it was a relationship that Haldir and the others did not know about. Also the ending where the mother just said to go with Haldir so she can stay with Eomer. I don't know, it felt selfish of her to stay with her love after meeting her daughter after 500 years! Like really?! It is something unimaginable to me, because my mother would give up everything for me, if I ever asked her. Not that I would really ask her that, because to me her happiness matters most. Her mother just seemed too childish, not mature enough. I felt as if she had no right to act motherly and adult-like, when she was so immature. Anyways, this is was my opinion, so don't go off on me!

Although, you did a good job writing this piece, the idea was new and original. So, hats off to you my friend!

I really liked this story a lot! I only wished there was a smoother transition between events at times. The story tho was a unique twist in the 'girl falls into ME' and I really liked that. More detail added would have only made it even better then it already was. Nice read_

A very beautiful st0ry...you are a wonderful writer

Truly Amazing, I loved every second i spent reading it.

I still love this story, even six years later! le hannon!

your story had so much emotion...continue to write :D

an amazing story! I completely loved it, thank you

an amazing story. im sad they sailed to valinor so soon tho

May I post this on wattpad for others to read your great skills and wonderful story

If you say yes I make sure I write it under your name.

please comment back...

This is a wonderful piece of work...

very touching and emotional...

I envy you and your many writings...

Hope you write more heart touching stories in the future and will give you all the support you deserve...