Loved it.

With so many uptake on this exhausted episode-faith-I almost doubt there's gonna be any new found regarding how this gonna be solved, but here it is. It's a good angle to look at it: Dean see how different it would be if Marshall didnt take his place regarding to their respective brothers. kuddos.

An extraordinarily well-written piece that pinpointed both characters with the sort of accuracy usually found in a laboratory. I don't know how I missed it before, but it was just what I needed right now. Thank you for sharing your insight, talent and imagination with this story.

This was, in all the respects I think important, perfect. For the episode. For the characters, both of them. For the show. You are a very talented writer. Thank you so much for writing!

When Sam crying and Dean hug him and soothing him, I'm so close to let my tears fall from my eyes !

That was just so asdfghjkl !

Goodness, I Freaking in Love with this !

Wow, I loved this! So angsty, but in an incredibly well-written and believable way. I loved the boys' interactions. This line, "Dean knew it wasn't what Sam meant, but deliberately misunderstanding was easier," really summed them up. Thanks so much for sharing!

This is brilliant. I liked finding out more about Marshall, and it bridges the gap between the episode and your episode nicely. :)

Brilliant follow up to Faith, totally believable that Dean would go visit Marshall's grave and also totally believable Sam's meltdown.
An awesome read.

Oh my, this is such a perfect little fic. I don't know how you managed to pull so many emotions out of me but you did. The story made me ache for Sam and Dean and the Marshall family.

And your descriptions and dialogue are better then the tv show.

I hope you write more SPN fics.

Great job.

Ah, the raw emotions. Just the right amount. Not totally unbelievable that these guys could go here. That was crazy satisfying. And since I read what comes next in Wyoming (In Reverse, right?), I actually feel like I have a bigger picture that makes this all the more satisfying. Awesome job.

(ignore the stupidity that my brain works so that when I end up writin a comment it is usually directed at a "character" in the story) * quickly wrapping Dean into a bear hug and the proceeding to drag him behind me( even though he's a foot taller and out weighs me too)* come on Dean , Sam's probally worried sick about you ... And you're soaked through , so you really need to get out of those wet clothes before you manage to get hypothermia or something

This was great! Loved the last line especially. Well done! :)

Beautiful *_*

Seriously, this was your first fic? Well, congratulations, wonderful starting D

I love faith and the whole scenery, the rain pouring down, Sammy desperate, and Dean hugging him and he's crying... OMG! D

Great! )

Kisses

Rosetta

I'm sorry this is not your personal favorite fiction that you've written - I do understand though, as this has happened to me alot, lol!

But I found this piece thoughtful, haunting, beautiful and moving - all while staying perfectly within the boys' characters! Brava, m'dear! And thank you for sharing this lovely piece of fic!

Very good story! I really love this one. On the top of my favorite Supernatural stories. It was like every paragraph and word was put there for a purpose. No rambling space-fillers. Everything had its place. My favorite kind of story!