Short, but pretty good, and obviously before TDH came out. Boy, and I thought JKR was cruel with how many characters she offed in the book. I actually think this could have been expanded, perhaps to show more of McGonagall's reactions to the angst her former students are going through. I did like the last line, of how Peter's death left Remus completely alone.

i liked this it was well done. i liekd the way at the end you added peter because even though he was evil it did leave lupin as the last of the 4. really liked your story

That was depressing but very good

nice name by the way

I like. I like A LOT. Beauty and pain and beauty all over again. I very much like.

that was so sad, but i still loved it. great job!

The Mistress of Shadows

Cool chapter it was interesting. continue cant wait to read more

Cool chapter it was interesting. continue cant wait to read more