Very good writing, I like the first chapter

I havery been looking for something like this forever THANK YOU SO MUCH

It's ringwraiths xD I'm just guessing but i have a feeling and 'Pointy-eared dainty stepping people' I died I kid you not i write this in heaven

I loved the I am no man quote

OH MY GOD...This story is SOOO AWESOME! I have so many things to say about it, and I'm not really sure where to start.

Okay, first is, I LOVE THIS STORY SO MUCH! It kept me reading on and on, and for those four days I was reading this, I really couldn't bear to put it down...but I had to. It's just like reading 'The Hobbit', there are so many things happening and you just can't put it down. At first, there was just a bit too much, well, fluff, and I had to read it on my phone so as not to let my younger brother see it accidentally. LOL. Yes, for real. But it was just those first ten or so chapters.

This amazing story kept me riding on an emotional roller coaster for FOUR WHOLE DAYS! Like, wow, it's just so good! You're so good at describing all those tiny details, like Aragorn's eye, for instance. And I actually cried a little at the part where Aragorn felt so heartbroken and the scenes were so touching...And it really takes quite a bit to make me cry. You are such a talented writer, that I must say. AWESOME STORY!

This was the most beautiful fic I have read. Ever. Really. The beginning had so much fluff that I thought I'd be okay, but it got so full of angst that I thought I'd die. I couldn't put it down except for sleep, and I very quickly finished this. Love every moment. You are SO talented. Thanks

I thought I'd return the favour and just let you know that this story is amazing! My first love will always be LOTR, I just can't write it. But I thought you've done beautifully on this. The characterisation is perfect and the story kept me on the edge of my seat. It was amazing!

i never wanted this story to end, but you have done so in a such a beautiful way that i suppose I am happy! Wonderfully done- you should be very proud!

This was such a beautiful story, thank you for sharing it with us. And the ending was perfect, so sweet!

Fabulous chapter! It was funny, sweet, exciting and well-written! Great job and I can't wait for the next update (though I'm sad that it will be the last!- perhaps a sequel is in the works?)!

i personally love fluff, but i think you went a bit overboard in this chapter. honestly it was almost sickening in the first part and i was wonderign when something would actually happen. we all get that arwen is happy to be alive, but really, does she have to worship aragorn? anyway, i hope the next chapter has something more than arwen's repetitive and boring meditations.

Alright this is in my opinion comepletely tearing apart the AragornArwen love story, but not just this chapter. I find this quite explicit, and I know it would be 100% better if you toned down the...yeah that. Other than that, it is cool to hear life as far as Aragorn and Arwen after the War of the Ring. I haven't seen much of their part in the appendices.

your writing never ceases to amaze so beautiful, it captures their relationship perfectly and sweetly for me:) i look forward to an update soon hopefully

great chapter! im so glad that arwen chose aragorn- i felt so badly for him! my heart nearly stopped when he told her to go! i also loved the friendship between arwen and eowyn in this chapter! please update soon- i hope the baby will make an appearance in the next chapter!

VERY. VERY. GOOD!