HOW COULD YOU PLAY WITH OUR FEELINGS LIKE THAT... YOU...

Snape should of had more than just a reprimand for his assault of Harry. He cause physical damage and caused Harry to pass out. You had him take things to far for him to remain teaching at Hogwarts.

How come I got to read this fanfic just now?! I have to admit I almost hexed your "username" to oblivion after reading chapter 11. Alas I had to give myself at least an hour before reading the final chapter because I was weeping uncontrollably out of anger and disappointment.. And then with fluffy eyes, I started reading this chapter, the final one - I was emotionally exhausted, I was thinking not to continue, like I thought there was no point anymore 'cause DAMN IT Minerva's dead anyway, AND I'M JUST SO GLAD I DID NOT! Still, after reading the final chapter, I was crying like a madwoman, but this time, the uncontrollable torrent of tears from my fluffy eyes were out of jubilation! MINERVA McGONAGALL IS ALIVE! YOU DID NOT KILL HER OFF! AND FOR THAT, I. THANK. YOU. *happy dance* You did a great job writing this fanfic :)

I cannot believe you fooled me like that. But I have to admit that I LOVE this story. I am now adding this story to my favorites

I totally regretted not seeing this story earlier. Bugger! You had me going that my most favorite character was 'gasp' dead! And what's with the ominous announcement? BTW, AWESOME story!

That was absolutely OUTSTANDING!

You completely had me going and yes I succombed to tears there for a moment.

Wow

That was absolutely amazing. Seriously. I was so angry at the end of chapter 11, I was going to stop reading but something made me carry on and by the end of chapter 12 I was laughing and crying like a lunatic! Loved the whole fic, I'm trying and failing to think of words to express how much I've enjoyed it!

That was beautiful. It really was.

But ... ummm ... What happened to Neville?

I loved the ending, really I did, but I was completely confused where he went off to.

But, apart from that one little stumbling block, your fic was pretty much perfect. Incredibly interesting, both the plotline and the writing itself.

Thanks for posting; I really enjoyed the fic.

this was a good story

i absolutely loved this story... until i got to the four years later part. that is the worst ending. but the rest of it is awesome

I don't know if you're still reading your rewiew but your story is amazing. I'd rather take that one for real instead of Rowling's one.

I didn't understand every single thing (I'm not a native speaker) but I found your story really moving!

Nice!

And I thought that Minerva McGonagall really died in the previous chapter...

You fooled me...

A wondrous finale for the story and I hope you'll continue writting!

blast you! I can't believe you made everyone think for almost the whole effin chappie that you had killed off Minerva! How could you! Thats just not right! You played with peoples emotions! GR! Btw great story but still ugh! I don't like you! Okay so yes I do but still! And how the hell did she have a kid? Isn't she like 60 or somethin like that? Meh. I don't wanna know. Anyways. Thanks for Writing this! You did great!

-Kristen-

It's just great!

That was exellect.