Reviews for Harry Potter & the Philosopher's Stone: Take Two
MotherBear chapter 3 . 9/5
Ok, really? Snape has more self discipline than to transfigure Dudley... he’d have been more likely to hit Vernon with something nasty.

I’m assuming he cast it weakly enough that it will wear off shortly?
MotherBear chapter 1 . 9/5
Rereading. Wow it’s been a long time!
uzumaki.namikaze10 chapter 2 . 7/15
goo
uzumaki.namikaze10 chapter 1 . 7/15
gchp
ILikeBooks chapter 1 . 5/27
Hello! I am a reader in 2020. after reading just this first chapter, I can tell it's going to be a good story. Thank you for writing this, Mysticsong1978
The Punmaster chapter 21 . 3/22
Love this.
mumphie chapter 21 . 12/15/2019
I truly enjoyed your story! I will look and see if you have finished your sequel. I hope so!
mumphie chapter 19 . 12/15/2019
Always wondered about canon...why wasn't Hagrid the ADULT? He should have met Charlie in Hogsmeade or on the top of the tower. Of course canon has sooo many things that make you go WHY!
Kittyhell chapter 21 . 11/29/2019
Oh my gods this was so good! Absolutely loved it!
Cinderfire16 chapter 7 . 11/28/2018
Oh fuck it's Lucius. Why WHY! Ugh. Now Snape's gonna have to deal with that slimy git. I wonder how he manages to walk the line so well. And then there's Quirrel. Who is also Trouble. It's nice to see Harry so curious about magic. He never seemed to ask enough questions in the earlier books and by the time book 5 rolled around all his questions were lashing out and I couldn't sit through much of it. Gonna do a reread at some point. See how different I see things.
Cinderfire16 chapter 6 . 11/28/2018
Okay good, Harry's getting a full introduction. Yay for Harry getting the what's what of Diagon Alley! Good eye for Snape on explaining the gold cauldrons! I had a similar explanation for one of my stories. Also: Snape the Potions Master doing right by a student is my favorite. I like this version of the guy so far.

THANK FUCK HE DIDN'T HAVE TO TELL MALFOY HIS NAME! even though Malfoy is still a little git. And thank you for having Snape explain everything. It'd be a shame if Harry felt betrayed by the first person to show him some sort of actual kindness. THAT might just turn him off people for good.

And they're at the Leaky... Oh dear.
Cinderfire16 chapter 5 . 11/28/2018
Ooooooh clever Harry. "I'm rich beyond my wildest dreams and absolutely no one else can no" you're damn right the Dursleys won't care what kind of money it is. Also: I doubt anyone likes the carts. I always headcanoned that the carts were used specifically by vault managers and people only went down when they wished to retrieve something. Thank you Snape for handling the money!
Cinderfire16 chapter 4 . 11/28/2018
"I am not seeing myself in Potter" keep telling yourself that, Sev.

I've always wondered where the "multiple vaults at Gringotts" thing came from. It's pretty good that Snape doesn't sugar coat things but I'm glad he's not being overly cruel either.

"A car accident kill Lilly and James Potter? I'm not even sure they owned a car." Best way of letting us realize that Snape is knowledgeable of both worlds. Have i mentioned that I love how you write?

And now Snape is pissed. Goin on a Rant.
Also "I need a drink" but points to Snape for sitting Harry down and telling him about the past. Hagrid did too but I always thought it was a bit rushed.

And we have the backstory! Plain terms, well done Snape. No sugarcoating or hesitation, something no one ever made clear but that happens in most battles "Light (wizards) don't play dirty and manybwere wiped out" extremely true. I think it's cool that Snape doesn't name the Secret Keeper but instead directs Harry to Dumbledore. Does he suspect the truth or think it's too much to go into?
SNAPE KNOWS VOLDIE'S REAL NAME! Does everyone, or is it just because he was a death eater?

I think it's interesting that you're giving Snape a Malfoyish twist on his background. What happened to his mother? Or was his father still an abusive prat?

Yay for nutrition potions! I hope Harry gets a checkup at Hogwarts.

"I know you must have questions. Thousands if you're anything like your mother." Kinda cute but who wouldn't?!
Cinderfire16 chapter 3 . 11/28/2018
I find it terribly convenient that Snape hadn't arrived two seconds earlier to see the literal closet they were keeping him in. Then again he'd likely explode. Ah, Snape. Keeps everything short and sweet and to the point. And... Oh wait. Harry doesn't know. Anything. I remember in the books they at least told him what happened to his parents but he literally doesn't know anything here and it's made really obvious by the way you write. That's amazing!

Oh snap, is Severus actually defending someone? Ha! He's like Godzilla. "I might be an ass to people but those are my people and I'm the only one who can be and ass to them!" Brilliant

Oh yeah Snape and Petunia recognize each other!

Clever that he changed the bacon instead of Dudley.

Go Harry go! There ain't no going back to all that mess.
Cinderfire16 chapter 2 . 11/28/2018
Ooooooh buddy, good looking out with the electrically charged air. That means TROUBLE! Of course Vernon is that despicable. But Harry sees McGonagall! One thing I always wondered about the letters is if anyone looked at where they were sent or if it was just automatic. I know Dumbledore explained his motivation down the line and the Doylist explanation is that everything would be different if he were raise normally, but still. Good luck getting that letter, Harry. Also: Dumbledore you fool. Oh shoot he actually sends Snape! I thought McGonagall was gonna go back to get him. DUMBLEDORE YOU FOOL! I hope McGonagall is the voice of reason throughout all this. She deserves better but she's also a badass. *cue Jaws theme*
This is gonna be greeeeat.
482 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »