| Reviews for Shadows and Scars |
|---|
anelawilliams chapter 11 . 1/24/2014 NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! You left me hanging and I was hanging on your every word. Please write more, please hurry. I have to know what is going to happen and you must make Legolas forgive Estel, they are the best of friends. You have to tell me what is going to happen once they get up on the mountains again. Please don't leave me hanging, I have tears in my eyes. |
Ocne chapter 11 . 3/9/2013 Love your story. Love you writing style. Love the angst and the tension between the characters. The story hasn't been updated for years. But I still come back to it, reread it and keep hoping that, someday, you will finish it. Any chance my hopes could be fulfilled? |
gginsc chapter 11 . 5/30/2012 This is a great story! I really wish you would finish it. |
msfgSA chapter 11 . 7/29/2010 Hi... three years later. Um , just stumbled across this story and it's sort of killing me that it's not finished... a little help? |
hitsuni chapter 11 . 5/28/2009 Please do continue this story.. I really love it so much. Came back to this story after a long while. Really miss reading your writing. |
estelstheone chapter 11 . 3/14/2009 Ho there! Your story is too good to be be left hanging. Any chance you'll ever update? Your writing is very unique and this story is a real nail biter. Please write back if you can. |
asdfjkl chapter 11 . 1/16/2009 your kidding, right? YOUR JUST GONNA LEAVE US THERE LIKE THIS! ai! that's evil. and mean. and horrible. and cruel. i mean, what happens! how does it all work out? i mean, poor estel! guy needs a major hug. meanie. xP |
loststolenandfound chapter 11 . 10/19/2008 wow! what a story! :D love it! really good awesome infact! please please please please please continue. would love to see the end! :D |
novelteas74 chapter 11 . 2/2/2008 OMG, has it been a month since you updated and I haven't reviewed? I'm afraid I lost the printed copy I had so I probably won't go into a lot of detail. GREAT CHAPTER. I enjoyed it immensely. You write with such an intensity and your characterizations are so vivid. All along this horrible misunderstanding between Estel and Legolas has seemed perfectly plausible and even the begrudging forgiveness Legolas offers, the same. That bird song they keep hearing...very interesting. And this: Yet, despite dusk approaching, it was becoming brighter as daylight finally began to break through the receding canopy. The oddness of this occurrence coupled with the strange silence of their old friend who appeared to be leading them nowhere in particular and seemingly further from their objective.' All very mysterious. You write mysterious incredibly well. The twins' attempt to persuade Estel to go back to the Grey Mountains. Wow! He is terrified to go there. Adventure, intrigue, pathos, humor, darkness and torment...I must say this story has it all. I just wish I had time to give it a proper review, but I'm actually trying to catch up on lots of reviews today as I no longer have much time to do it. Dratted work! Hope to see another chapter sometime within the next few months. |
grumpy123 chapter 11 . 1/2/2008 Good to see the twins are there. Estel has been found and lost again. Go back to the mountains, sounds like they are going to have to tie him up, to go back there. |
Hello Anyone There chapter 11 . 12/31/2007 Poor Estel, he's not having the easiest of times at the moment is he? How on earth did he manage to outrun two elves when he is mortal, wounded and had been travelling all day? I loved your other stories, especially the second one. Estel as a boy was brilliant, i really liked your portarayal of him. Keep writing! |
lady angst chapter 11 . 12/31/2007 oh, that was a good chapter I'm glad you updated! It was a great chapter, very emotional |
lostinterestsorry chapter 11 . 12/31/2007 Well worth the wait. Great chapter. All very intriguing as regards that mysterious birdsong and Estel's fear about going back to the Grey Mountains. (Though I do hope you take the story there and explain in more detail just what happened to make Estel act so strange or have some horrible/mysterious/hair-raising events happen when they do go back not that that's a suggestion or anything!) I like a suspicious Legolas. Nice to have an elf who doesn't act like a soddin' 15-year-old in a story. We need strong elves who come across as the ancient beings they are - even Legolas is pretty old when you think about it (and yeah, I know, he's still young for an elf but he has been around awhile anyway)! Thanks for making him seem more mature than most fics do. Glad that Elladan and Elrohir got to see their brother again too. I'd tell you to hurry up and get the next chapter going but I'm hardly one to talk. Still, will be glad to read it. |
StarLight9 chapter 11 . 12/31/2007 This is great! Hope the next update will come soon ;) |
Shrimp chapter 10 . 9/29/2007 Write more? Soon? |