Absolutely beautiful. The last few paragraphs and especially that quote made me almost cry.

There just isn't enough Crope/Tibbett love out there and this is definitely going in my favourites.

Oh, this was so sad and lovely. The last line really hits hard. The flow and the dialouge were fantastic and the blooming of their relationship was so well-done. My favorite part had to be when they would have debates and not realize it. That spoke volumes. This was such a gorgeous fic, especially because of the total lack of Crope/Tibbett. (Crobbett *snort*)

Wow. Every time I think about Crope and Tibbet and the Philosophy Club, I just wanna cry. Actually, I wanna slaughter that bastard Avaric and then cry. But not because I killed Avaric.

Man, it was all nice and happy at first and then it hit me hard by making me have to remember the PC which I try desperatly to forget...

Poor Tibbet. And Crope, too. They deserved better, I think.

On a lighter note, they remind me of New Yorkers. _; I know that sounds kinda weird, but think about it. Can't you just see them roaming the streets and shops of SoHo and all, parading around in electric blue or neon pink or a violent shade of orange... Heh.

Sad, but lovely. Great fic.

Oh, I cannot tell you how grateful I am to have found this. This is exactly what I was looking for every since I finished Wicked: my Tibbett closure. You're absolutely right, he and Crope were characters that should have been better represented (if the book wasn't a mighty tome already, anyway) and you did a beautiful job portraying them.

I guess I was always wondering how he deteriorated and what it did to Crope, as well as how they met and what they were like; basically, things that were all offscreen, per se, in the book, and of course can be covered in full in the fandom. And it has! Thank you so much.

Yay Cribbet (lol)! I'm putting this on my favorite's list! BRILLIANT! And there's a massive lack of Crope and Tibbett fics out there!

CROPE AND TIBBETT!

this was awesome. and sad. and there needs to be more crope'n tibbett fic.

Well, this is amazing. There's no reason to be subtle about how in awe I am over it - it's amazing. Your beautiful dialogue skills aside, this story is just filled with beautiful and heartbreaking descriptions. Why ISN'T there any Crope and Tibbett (Cribbett - snort!) fic out there? How I yearn to be inspired.

Anyway, I loved it.

Beautiful. Great writing, I really liked it. This is actually my first Wicked fic I've read (which is surprizing, cuz I love it to death) and the funny thing is, I was thinking, gee, It'd be cool to find a Crope and Tibbett story, maybe I'll write one, and then I saw your's just right there and I'm like... oh... coolness _ But excelent job, keep it up!

You have made me EXTREMELY happy. I've been looking for CropexTibbett fics ever since I finished Wicked. The lack of them has me starting my own; but I'm so glad I found yours! It's wonderful! :hugs fic: I'm faving it! It's really sad though, for as humourous as the two were- they were destined to be tragic, weren't they? Anyways, now I shall get back to work on mine! Thanks for the inspiration!

Crope & Tibbett are two of my favorite characters from the book, & I was beyond happy to see a story dedicated to the two of them. I love the dynamic between them in the beginning of the story, especially when they first met. Instant chemistry. And the end really hits you hard. You know it's coming, but that doesn't make it any harder to read.

Sorry for rambling. You've put out an excellent piece of fiction.

Aww. The end bit brought biddy tears to my slash craving eyes.

This was a fabulous piece. THANK YOU, YOU LOVELY LOVELY DARLING FOR WRITING SOME CROPE/TIBBETT. It's a wonderful thing, slash, when it's done properly. Especially such a fabulously wonderfully canon couple like Crope and Tibbett. Honestly, when I read the book I about died for the canon-ness of them. They are adorable and you've captured their personalities beautifully.

Thank you again for writing this.

This is so sweet! They were my favorite minor characters in that book. This is just great, really it is.

I saw "Tibbett and Crope" in the summary, and had to read this; it's very well done, and I must applaud you - you captured my image of them wonderfully, and I agree, there aren't enough Crope and Tibbett stories out there. Good work!

Yay, more slash, and canonical too. Not that I'm really into it, but you write so well that I can overlook that fact. I like how this is not raunchy but subtle instead. I actually found this story to be rather moving. You've excellently captured Crope's sense of loss. Mayhaps slash wouldn't be so bad if everyone wrote it as well as you did. Nice job!

P.S. I look forward to reading the next chapter of "Reciprocity."