This might have worked better then kidnapping. At least then the Order wouldn't be called out and Dumbledore would have been there to help.

Yes, that definitely would have made things much simpler. Of course, they would have been much less interesting too. I'm glad that you went the way you did on True Identities, but I like this one-shot too. It's always fun to read "what-if" stories. Update soon (True Identities I mean).

What do I think? I think you should update "True Identities". You've developed a situation and then left us all on a cliffhanger...and instead of posting another chapter..you post this? Okay, okay, it's not that bad, but really, I would have rather of had this posted after you finished "True Identities". It's good, but PLEASE, get back to work .

Will the test be done? How will it be known whether or not Harry is Edward?