Very good and quite different from any other story I have read.

This was friggen awesome! Holy crap you are amazing!

Absolutely amazing, I cried and laughed and worried; all things that show how beautiful this fic is.

Interesting ending and HA to Sirius for what became of him. I like how things stuck to the books but also twisted nicely by taking a character out while all making sense. Great job well thought out and original. I enjoyed this story and thanks for sharing.

Grr, flippin' Dumbledore! I can imagine him doing that though.

Aww, poor Severus. I bet Lupin would stay away from the shack after what took place there. Things would definitely play out different since Severus isn't there. It all makes sense.

Sounds like something Dumbledore would do to save his own skin. Just wonder how he explained the incident to Snape's parents and the condition of his remains.

Wow, great gory start! I can't wait to continue.

Aw, I wish there was more about Harry and Severus' afterlife together. They are super cute! I wish there was more! You did a great job with this story! :)

-Yvonne

A fantastic, but incredibly sad, story.

What a fantastic story! I first read this a few years ago, and it definitely has held up over time! Great job :)

That was fantastic! Such a unique idea (hard to find in this fandom lol), and it was written so well! I absolutely loved every word!

This story was beautifully tragic, haunting, and horrifyingly believable. I always wondered about the supposed 'prank', and why nothing had been done to punish Sirius. Well done; I really enjoyed it.

Ok...Now that was an amazing story. And so different from basically any other story I've ever read. Great job :)

Yikes. We're off to a dark start (that really high-lights of f:ed up canon is) and I'm hooked. Well written.