Such a beautiful good-bye! and thank you for being the only one to use the plot point that there is such an age range, but that Gandalf is older than Ea itself!

I love the story! It was great, I felt bad for Aragorn at parts, I know I hate being left out of things. I can only imagine what it feels like when the people around you have thousands of years on you. But I thought the story was the sweetest thing I had read in a long time! Write more stories!

Nicely done and well thought out. It took me a while to understand what you meant about December not being Midwinter. You see, in the Northern Hemisphere, Midwinter IS in December. Here we sometimes talk about "Christmas in July".
A blessed Yuletide to you and your friends and kinfolk,
Entspinster

Oh what a wonderful story Aims. Long... very long, longer then I expected even but it's all good. It was so sweet and cute when the opened their presents, and that snowball fight was very amusing. Though it's a shame Arwen didn't get hit :p
Good stuff Aims... this was a really grand and christmasy story. Now I hope I will see snow soon _
Merry Christmas lovey and enjoy RotK :*

Wonderful story! I love stories involving Elrond and his family, especially when Aragorn is included. This was so sweet and very nicely written.
I just have one problem. Isn't Endor the world in Star Wars where the Ewoks live?

Oh wow, that was fantastic! What a brilliant idea for a story! GREAT job! It was sweet, funny, and all-around wonderful! Write more stories! :)

Hi! This is very cute! I liked it :) I really liked Gandalf in this story. Everyone being so happy is a bit sad (weird sentence!) they have so much grief in their lifes.. :(
I thought Glorfindel was of the 'House of the Golden Flower', because being of the Golden House of Finarfin he would be Galadriel's brother/nephew? That sounds like an interesting story, I would love to read more about it!

Great job! Is there more to come?