This was great! I liked the idea of what would have happened if Sirius was in Slytherin and he was still friends with James! I think you got their characterizations right!

Sirius was in Gryffindor. In the 6th Harry Potter Slughorn says it and in the 7th Harry, Ron and Hermione are at his home and his room his red and gold...

That was freakin' amazing. :)

Very well-thought out, given the available information at the time.

Just the description behind it, without revealing too much, had me gripped.

Excellent story, and this is going in my favorites!

i guess the friendship between james and sirius are really unbreakable, no matter what the others think. i love your reference to R&J, how adorable :D

loved it!

(: love it! (: I kinda of like the idea of Sirius being in Slytherin (:

Hagrid just isn't that bright and conveniently forgot a bout Sirius Black because he has a intense and understandable hatred of Slytherin.

I thought that sirius was in gryffindor, hence his mutterings about his family rejecting him because he went into the wrong house...

And James was a chaser, he was only a seeker in the movie.

Good job - very realistic.

Oh wow! I never really thought about Sirius being a Slytherin. This was great, and adorable! I loved it. It's going on my faves.

This was great! Great characterisation of both boys, I never read a fic where Sirius was such a strong character, and so in character! Great plot, I liked he Beater Padfoot! It's a pitty it isn't canon, but because it's so brilliant, it still goes to my favs! And I noticed you wrote only 2 HP fics... I hope you continue, even if this was written 5 years ago... By the way, this site you mentioned, it's something wrong with it...

Now, really, just give some sign of writting... ;)

Very nice, well thought-out story. I'm glad to have read it.

Intriguing idea...Sirius the characterisation!

Right now, I can't remember if his house was mentioned in HBP... but either way, quite awsome. So I'm assuming Remus is Ravenclaw and Peter, Hufflepuff? Or am I wrong? hm... but really quite wonderful. I love seeing how people explore the aspects of inter-house friendships.

**DUckies