Wow, this is an amazing story! I love how you imitate Tolkien's style so well, and I'm really looking forward to our friends meeting Harry and the others.

i like this fic and think it shows great promisecan't wait to see how it turns out and how much of a role harry will play

very interesting start. You are excellent writer and I like this story a lot.

please continue :P

your writing style is kick ass… John would be soo proud. John as in John Ronald Reuel Tolkien :D

I read in your profile that you were going to basically dicontinue/semi-abandom this fic, which would really and truely suck, so please don't. if you already have stopped this story, could you please post a notice in the actual story stating this?

if you decide to continue this fic, it would be much appreciated.

Reasons to continue on (please):

- this is a very creative plot line that several have tried to do, and most of them have failed. unlike those before, you have actually managed to do this in a believable and well written way.

- your wordage (for lack of a better term) is quite good, it reflects the style of J.R.T. amazingly well.

- it seems that I am not the only fan of this work.

- so what if J.K.R. screwed us all with the fifth book, make it AU and stick your tounge out at the authoress :P.

- there are too few good Harry Potter/ Lord of the Rings crossovers.

- other comment that can be placed here that fits.

Reasons to stop (badbadbadpleasedon'tbad):

- J.K.R. betrayed us all with the fifth Harry Potter book, OotP.

- not enough time, if this is the case, I understand.

- something else

wow, this is the longest review I've ever written. if anything said gives offense, please note that none was in anyway intended. until whenever, ja ne :)

Please tell me that this isn't abandoned? I'm a fan of unlikely crossovers that work, and this one does! More, please?

when is the next chapter coming out

Amazing! This is like the work of Tolkien himself! I normally can't stand cross overs, especially Harry Potter ones, but this is simply worderful!

This goes against everything I hold dear, but it looks so good!*wimper*

Oh my goodness, I've looked long for a story much like this one, a Harry Potter/Lord of the Rings Crossover that has merit and an excellent author. Please continue, please, please, please.

C.T.

Hello there, I can be very impatient unfortunatly, and well, who are the people in the cloaks, I think I know who they are, but then I get all the more confused, umm...let me see, I think one is Lady Galadrial, one is Lord Elrond, and tha other is Legolas...at least I think so, anyways, please tell us...or at least you can tell me...lol...hope to read more soon! And if it isn't to much to ask, can you e-mail me the title of the story please, because I have a very poor memory of things!

Laters,

Inwe Nolatari

So, I'm pretty much in love with your story. I love everything about your style of writing. Then I saw the date of your last update... and just about cried. I seriously hope you continue this story.

Thanks for the awseome read

You know I have been looking for a good crossover with these two stories and I have found it in your story so far, but not updating it in a couple of years almost makes me wish I didn't start the story. I hope you update sooner or later. Preferably the former.

so I take it this story is abandoned if not update would you it's one of the few crossovers that's completely convoluted and terrible in general.

Wow! This is story is amazing. You have really taken it one step further. I love how you take the time to explain things and I really like the quotes at the beginning of the chapters. I am in complete awe. I really hope you update soon.