| Reviews for The Good War |
|---|
H Bregalad chapter 10 . 7/26 very impressive chapter, I like the thought you've put into kick turns, and that they are a thing everyone gets told about eventually, but liz invents for herself without knowing. I like your portrayal of Liz trying to do the right thing, but only managing in an absentminded and rude sort of way. being a kid is like that, more to the point, cross-cultural experience tends to be like that. |
Inoeth chapter 10 . 7/26 Wow. That was quite the chapter- the quidditch was very fun and I look forward to your narration of an actual match. I also like how you have handled the Liz/Draco thing and i'm curious to see how things continue to play out as they get older. On the other side was the very, very heavy scene with Tracy - well written and interesting for sure but very heavy. Makes me really want to keep reading to see what happens next |
SeekerOfShadows chapter 10 . 7/26 It's incredible! You're making me feel so many things with this fic. Keep it up author, you're awesome |
prettypinkcake chapter 10 . 7/25 Wow. This is good. Very good. Quite different to a lot of other fics I’ve read, but definitely one I want to read more of. I just love your Snape. He’s got intricacies and depths that make him a character I want to know more about. I can’t say I fully understand Liz. My heart goes out to her, and I can only hope that she learns to accept the love and support of those who care about her. Thank you for writing this intriguing story. I’m anxiously and impatiently looking forward to the next chapter. |
Taiyong Medical chapter 10 . 7/24 It’s nice to read a fic that doesn’t sink to wizard equivalent of eugenics apologetism but doesn’t portray slytherins as irredeemable antagonists despite the main character being one. Also protective Marcus Flint? Yes please. |
RedShirt1453 chapter 10 . 7/24 Tracey would likely feel better had Lizz showed her own scars. |
Uday Sra chapter 10 . 7/24 Good |
gnurd chapter 10 . 7/23 I love how you've written Liz here. It's so good with her responses to rewards and punishments being how she deals with the world. |
DireApostasy chapter 10 . 7/23 I do so love reading the continuing adventures of Liz attempting to remember how to people... when she can be arsed and it's not entirely too much effort. :D |
Bearmauls chapter 9 . 7/21 I assumed that Liz still had a sort of automatic tendency to underperform on written material due to the Dursleys. She knows she doesn't need to hide her intelligence anymore, but she did have a few years of that being necessary and it isn't easy to just undo that sort of learned behaviour. Snape is interesting, as always. Dumbledore is awful and useless. Hope Flamel tore more strips off him. The idea of metamorphs being naturally immortal, but kinda detached from identity is pretty interesting! |
Bearmauls chapter 8 . 7/21 That was a brilliant magical fight. Dora is awesome. Seeing Dumbledore get smacked down is always good times. |
Bearmauls chapter 7 . 7/21 Jeez, did not expect that. It does seem like Liz complaining/telling Snape that Quirrel is constantly attacking her with mind magic, and that this soul magic attack happened immediately after such an attack by Quirrel. Does Snape not know? |
Bearmauls chapter 6 . 7/21 That battlemagic book sounds AMAZING! I want one :) Liz should probably find a way to practice her mind control superpowers, she's encountering a number of people who've completely thrown her for a loop. The Christmas card from Dorea made me cry. Well done. Actually the whole opening presents sequence was just beautiful. Mentor Snape is... kinda adorable? Not sure how you pulled that off, though... |
Bearmauls chapter 5 . 7/21 Way to fake us out on the troll! Nice that Ellie revealed some info to her friends? I guess we can call them friends. You've made Snape really interesting. |
Bearmauls chapter 4 . 7/21 Snape is going to lose his shit. This chapter was intense, but really really good. |