| Reviews for The Joke's On You |
|---|
Kelsey441 chapter 5 . 9/24/2016 This was quite cute. |
Kelsey441 chapter 1 . 9/23/2016 Awww. Fred melted. I love how the chater just ends like that. |
Cydrose chapter 5 . 12/13/2012 I really enjoyed your characterization of Fred in this story and a unique view of events. One small thing though, you've classified this story as George and Eloise when it's really Fred... |
Ripley chapter 2 . 11/17/2010 I like this a lot :) Everyone is IC and Eloise is relatable and human. Just two minor niggles in chapter two: colour "co-ordinated" rather than "coated", and "autumn" rather than "fall"; other than that, great! |
Guest chapter 5 . 11/23/2008 This was a great story. I like how you started with an insecure character and turned her into a brave one. I also liked how the main character isn't pretty/talented at everything. Great moral. A bit mushy at times, but still, it was a really good story. ) |
XfallenstarO chapter 5 . 10/25/2008 So totally sweet and funny! |
ebdarcy.qt4good chapter 5 . 3/3/2008 Great story! I loved it! :D |
Go10 chapter 5 . 1/19/2008 I actually read this story this past Thanksgiving but I didn't leave a review because I was afraid you'd take my honest feelings about it the wrong way but now since I see that you actually appreciate the honesty behind my reviews I'd just want to say that I feel that this story might've been stronger if you had just let Fred die at the end, like he did in DH and make Elle face her bullies without him. I think his death, combined with Elle coming to deal with it and coming out stronger in the end would've made for a more emotional finish. And oh, this is offtopic but I just realized that the side plotline thingy you had in A Sketch of Character where Teddy tries to get to know little Scorpio is actually a great fanfiction story in itself, I'd love to see you write it. Anyway, Happy New Year to you too |
UncontrollableInsanity chapter 5 . 9/15/2007 This one was one of my earmarked stories, like, FOREVER, because you wouldn't bloody update! It's so bittersweet, because we all know what really happens to Fred... I thoroughly enjoyed what happened to Eloise, just another name in the books. Thank you for finally finishing it. |
KittKatt001 chapter 5 . 9/4/2007 Oh amazing! I'm so glad you finished it :) Terrific job, very happy about the change you made from Deathly Hallows... that was so sad in the book :( Great job! Loved it completely and utterly :) |
Nyos chapter 5 . 8/30/2007 OMG! O THANK GOD! THANK YOU~ It didn't happen exactly like in HPTDH, which makes me cry in relief! |
Poseidon's Chickadee chapter 4 . 9/5/2006 *Sighs* So much for no drama. Oh, well drama adds to the fun! Please update SOON! |
Poseidon's Chickadee chapter 2 . 9/5/2006 *squeals!* And I love this Fred. He's not a HUGE git, not even a little one. And George doesn't use Fred as a clutch. Yay! |
Poseidon's Chickadee chapter 1 . 9/5/2006 O! This going to be a good one I just know it. But thus far I like ALL your stories, so ... However, this one seems more simple, not in a boring way but in a sweet way. No huge drama, or arguing, just danged sweet. Then again this was just the first chapter :-P |
Megan chapter 4 . 8/1/2006 I really like this story. It's original, cute and funny. I don't know if you're still looking for a beta for it, but if you are, feel free to send me an email. |