Reviews for Phantasmal Soldier
FabledLife chapter 2 . 8/29
For all of those who keep on saying that Shirou's projections (Traced Version) last as long as he wants them to or broken then NO, that is not how it works. That only works on mundane/ordinary objects like cups, dishes, and etc.

Ex: Due to the extra effort, it is possible to produce incredibly stable ordinary items that can remain in the world seemingly indefinitely after their creation, unless broken or dismissed.

The reason why Shirou's traced weapons/objects don't last long is because they are slightly inferior to the originals due to the fact that only so much information can be gathered by sight alone, and Noble Phantasms are degraded by an entire rank. Because of the degradation/incompleteness, the items are not everlasting, thus are recognized by the world as a phantasm that doesn't belong in the natural world, and will be erased as an inconsistency. The better the image in the caster's imagination, the more stable and longer lasting the object will be, and it can be further improved by having technical knowledge of its construction, such as a blueprint, or having materials to overlay the desired shape upon.
WesternReader chapter 3 . 8/18
Why does everyone keep making Shirou's projections impermanent? They last until they're broken from what I understood.
Bubbahfearsome chapter 6 . 8/17
what a mean cliffhanger to put there
Dragon Man 180 chapter 6 . 8/16
Those mages are crazy... ugh, politics make me sick.
ruggdamon4 chapter 6 . 8/16
When will Rory come along?
TorstenL chapter 6 . 8/16
Great Chapter!
And Shirou gets more trouble!
Z.L.C. genesmith chapter 6 . 8/15
I take it Arpeggio is coming along? I wonder how she'll react to seeing her little sister at Alnus with Itami.
formerlyarandomreviewer chapter 6 . 8/15
Definitely for the best that Shirou didn't try tracking with Hrunting because Hrunting doesn't work that way last I saw. It'll home in on a target, but only if you're aiming at it.
Jebest4781 chapter 6 . 8/15
gonna be interesting to see what'll come up next
FabledLife chapter 6 . 8/15
Let me guess, Arpeggio is gonna join with Shirou to the Alnus Hill... Welp, Shirou's Ex Rank Clueless Chick Magnet is kicking in right now, though is it gonna increase even further when he gets back to the base in the first place while meeting with the other Special Zone people and will his E Rank Luck kick in as well?
FabledLife chapter 1 . 8/2
There are 2 reasons why magecraft is kept secret to the populace. First is that the more people draw from it at the same time, the more Magecraft’s capacities become mundane. In short, the greater is the collective number of magi, the weaker their individual power. Like say for example, if someone has a magecraft that let's one fire off 1000 spears and then another person learns the same magecraft, it leads to the both of them to fire only 500 spears now. The second reason is because the ambient Mana in the atmosphere of Earth is slowly dwindling right now ever since the end of The Age of Gods, thus making Mana limited to all magus's. Most if not all magus's relies on Mana as it is the greater source of raw Magical Energy that surpasses their own Od (life-force Magical Energy) thus letting them be able to use more of their own magecraft. The more Mana there is in the air, the easier it is for a Magus to be able to use their magecraft. For those who don't know, Magus's can't directly use Od or Mana for their spells as they are Magical Energy in it's RAW state, that is where Magic Circuits are there to process them into usable Magical Energy to be able to cast their spells.
A Fan chapter 1 . 7/5
That's... Not why magic is kept a secret. But whatever, I'm not going to plug-in a huge wall of text of the real reason. You should just fact check things before writing them, or say in an AN that some things might be changed/wrong. I still enjoy this because I'm not a stickler for details.
Angron chapter 3 . 7/5
t would have been much better to use Chaldea than the special and overused child of "Shirou Emiya" or in your case an OC with a name and appearance of Shirou Emiya.

Also like other writers you misunderstand Shirou's skills.

Matte objects made by Gradation Air don't last very long but Matte objects made by Shirou's Projection last indefinitely (disappear if they break or if Shirou wants them to disappear)

Rin:"…Fine. I guess if I'm going to correct you, we'll have to start with the fundamentals. But let's go back to what we were talking about earlier. Is it true that the thngs you projected are still in your shed?”
Shirou:“Yeah. Things don’t normally go away unless you break them, right?”

That dialogue perfectly indicates that Shirou's projections exist indefinitely.

Due to certain events that happened, they allowed humans not to depend on the gods and the supernatural. Humans decided to be independent, trust science and their own knowledge and advance as a civilization.

Gaia obeys the laws of the most prosperous species on the planet's surface.

The only reason why Gaia hates humans is because they will be able to survive when the planet dies and Gaia didn't like that.

Because the humans decided to be assholes with the planet and they will continue living on a corpse (dead planet), Gaia asked for help, thus the Ultimate One and Primate Murder emerged.

It must also be remembered that in Nasuverse the GODS and divine spirits are different, the GODS have their full powers and the divine spirits are the remains of the gods.

the gods in Gate - Jietai Kare no Chi nite, Kaku Tatakeri do not function exactly like the GODS and divine spirits in NAsuverse, so profavro do not treat as if they were the same.

the disoes in Gate - Jietai Kare no Chi nite, Kaku Tatakeri depend on the planet to continue existing. In Nasuverse the GODS and divine spirits do not have that limitation of existence.
FabledLife chapter 4 . 7/4
Though of course the projections won't disappear immediately as it takes a while for the World/Gaia to recognize them as phantasms to be eliminated...
Jebest4781 chapter 5 . 7/4
it'll be fun to see what'll occur next in this
74 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »