| Reviews for The Polyjuice Club |
|---|
mamabear888 chapter 1 . 7/17 Really enjoyable story. Loved it! |
Penny is wise chapter 2 . 6/7 Awesome story. Loved the idea and I really like how you portrayed everyone. |
Sammi chapter 1 . 6/1 I love this story so much 3 definitely one of my favorites! |
Anon chapter 2 . 2/23 Speedy, fun to read and clearly well though out. Very much enjoyed. |
Ashaisha chapter 2 . 2/12 Thank you! It was original, fun and touching! I love how Ron and Hermione take care of Harry by taking a seat at the Dursleys. I loved your story, your ideas and the relationships between the characters. Except for Fleur. I had a great time, thank you very much for sharing it. |
mooneysfate chapter 2 . 2/11 wonderful story! :) this is what should have happen! :) |
PrettyGirlBPD13 chapter 2 . 2/7 I feel like “eater of Voldemort” is a much better title than “defeater of Voldemort” because it requires the personal sacrifice of your taste buds. Yuck! But I always enjoy fics (all maybe three I’ve read) where Remus is ultimately responsible for ending their dark lord problem and accidentally starts a werewolf rights movement. This was a great fic! |
PrettyGirlBPD13 chapter 1 . 2/7 This is entirely too much fun! Strangely, one of the highlights is Perfect Percy giving Harry obvious hints (amazing, compass, ball of twine) about the third task. I adore everyone rallying around Harry the way I always wished they would in canon. Yes, he was always going to be a target of Voldemort but that never should’ve meant he needed to fight mostly on his own with so many capable witches and wizards around him. And Cedric and Viktor joining their group was just icing on the cake. |
MrsFH chapter 2 . 2/5 Excellent story - thanks for sharing it! |
teachergirl chapter 2 . 2/3 I really enjoyed this story. It was a lot of fun to read. |
ObsessedWithHPFanFic chapter 2 . 2/1 It's great that the Ministry actually cleaned up the DEs. Fun ending and thanks for sharing! |
ObsessedWithHPFanFic chapter 1 . 2/1 Great story concept and nicely done with the writing. Thanks for sharing! |
lunaz chapter 2 . 1/31 enjoyed reading this, thanks. |
fruitbat728 chapter 2 . 1/31 Re: guest reviews Re: Goblin 214, Amista, and Alba Thanks for reading, glad you enjoyed it. :) Re: Alba Good question. This isn't explicitely stated in the story, but from reading the books I assume that house elves are pretty powerful and either the Ministry cannot detect house elves or house elves can mimic wizard magic. We also know that house elves are underestimated. When Dobby got Harry in trouble before second year he did it on purpose, possibly mimicking Harry's magic. In this story, he can also conceal their magic from the Ministry's detection in the same way that house elves arent detected. As to why he hadn't been getting Harry food already, Harry didn't ask. Hermione hired him immediately in this story, but in canon we don't see him again until Harry visits the kitchens in his fourth year. I hope that makes sense. ~fruitbat |
alba chapter 1 . 1/31 Good story but right from the beginning saw some errors, first if it was so easy to have Dobby help Harry get around the lack of food etc why wasn't it done before which brings us to the second question, Harry got charged with misuse of magic when Dobby used magic, ie drop a cake at the Drusley's home. Why can Dobby get away with doing that now helping Hermionie? |