| Reviews for Harry Potter and a Mother's Gift - Year 1 |
|---|
amkarb01 chapter 11 . 10/26/2019 You have a lot of spelling errors but other than that it is great |
jmanfitzwater chapter 20 . 2/26/2019 Awesome fic. Looking forward to a sequel if there is one. |
RoseTennant654 chapter 20 . 2/26/2019 patiently and excitedly waiting for a part 2. |
jmw03u chapter 20 . 2/14/2019 I really like this story. I thought your original bits were really fun and even though they went along with JK’s storythey fit really well. That being said, it would be great if in the future you could distinguish between JK and stuff and yours. Maybe by having either your original content or JK’s content and bold or italics? Or putting a little marker at the beginning and the end of JK’s stuff? It’s not that I object to you putting JK’s stuff in there. I get that sometimes JK just says stuff better than you can think to change it or you don’t really want to change her original content much, you just want to add stuff in there. It’s that I’ve already read her stuff a lot and I would really like to be able to just skim through it since I already know all of it and get to your story faster. Overall I really enjoyed your work. Thank you for writing this. |
spawn1237 chapter 20 . 1/1/2019 Good start for a snake mentors Harry story, but at least this year was very close to cannon. I would be interested to see you veer further away from the cannon story year 2. Horcrux diary and basilisk make sense but should play out differently if Harry trusts Snape and shares with him more. |
minimonstr9 chapter 1 . 1/1/2019 Ok, so the grammar isn’t perfect and it follows fairly close to the original story but I love reading it! Please keep writing this! |
Gajevyaddict chapter 20 . 12/28/2018 omg. I just finished this all in a few hours and am distraughy that the rest of the books arent up yet. I can't wait to read more. this was amazing! |
Lauraf68 chapter 20 . 12/26/2018 Thank you for a great story! |
NatFord123 chapter 1 . 12/25/2018 This is so sweet! I love the ways you incorporate the Snape and Harry relationship with the original story. Please continue on to year 2! |
He-Who-Shall-Live chapter 1 . 12/23/2018 Just...no. Grammar, spelling mistakes, bad sentence structure...not to mention all the changes to the story that STILL somehow ends up being canon... Just no. Plan better. Get a Beta. |
Ptitkactus chapter 19 . 12/23/2018 I honestly can't keep reading this... I mean, with all the changes you made, how can your story stick so much to canon :( |
nmg1357 chapter 6 . 12/23/2018 Is Sintra supposed to be Sinistra? And if so, Professor Vector is the Arithmacy professor while Sinistra is he Astronomy professor |