Ooh interesting idea. Well done.

Awwwww! I loved this fic!

MY FEELS! I’m so glad that Neal called on Rumplestiltskin. It would be just like Hook to turn him into the bad guy in all his stories.

The thing about this story that hits home with me is how plausible it is. Emma does tend to overlook certain peoples flaws. Hook does tend to be self centered. Taken to new lengths...

Awesome story! Glad Neal gets a new family!

Where was Henry? I am glad to see he finalky got happiness in the end, especially with Belle, because lets be honest, she'd be an amazing Mom.

If Snow and Charming did ever wake up, I think David would be furious at Snow for making the decision to orphan Neal.

Well Emma is horrible right off the start referring to her father as David. They are BOTH her parents not just Snow. That just pissed me off

Great and heartbreaking story. I can see that with such circumstances and Emma’s obsession with Hook their live may end like this. Anyway I'm glad that Neal finally find real home for himself. Thank you for the story

Kelanie, you broke my heart with this. I am happy Neal is with people who will love him and do right by him and Gideon will have a playmate! May Killian rot in hell! I do wonder where Regina and Henry went though?