| Reviews for A Dramatic Reading |
|---|
Saskya chapter 17 . 7/21 Amazing story |
MonsterMaster chapter 13 . 7/23 Great chapter ! |
Guest chapter 18 . 7/19 Thanks for sharing |
Guest chapter 10 . 7/19 This really is fun. |
Guest chapter 2 . 7/19 This is quite good. |
excessivelyperky chapter 5 . 7/19 Well, at least Harry was allowed to have friends at Hogwarts, while Snape was persecuted and nearly murdered for having just one. And I have always thought that Dumbledore cut down Harry's time at the Dursleys the summer after Sirius' death because Snape saw what was going on during the Occlumency lessons (funny how Harry only needed two weeks there once people other than Dumbledore knew the Dursleys were abusive, amazing how they found out, right?). But I don't mind Snape making plans. We all know what Dumbledore's plans for Snape were, don't we, and how well they worked to keep Harry alive and Snape dying in agony. It might be a very good idea if Snape could get a copy of books six and seven really soon now. Why isn't Harry asking Minerva why he had to spend all of each year at the Dursleys before Hogwarts? If he only needs two weeks (per Albus in Half-Blood Prince), why did he have to be abused by them year round? You have to wonder if Harry is the only abused kid at Hogwarts, and why nobody seems to even consider the possibility that there are more. Great move by Sirius with the mirror, though. It will probably end up saving his life. |
excessivelyperky chapter 4 . 7/18 Of course it's humorous when something bad happens to a Muggle (although Hermione may see things somewhat differently). And I'm really sure that Hermione isn't the only one with questions about how Harry has been treated. (but of course it was perfectly all right for Snape to be treated the way he was...because he exists). |
excessivelyperky chapter 3 . 7/18 I wonder if the school will be as amused as we all were about Dudley's being turned into a pig? After all, Hagrid had no idea who Dudley was except he was a Muggle. But I can see the school falling over in laughter over it. |
excessivelyperky chapter 2 . 7/17 Actually, if vulnerable magical children receive visits, then why didn't Snape have anyone on his side when he was a kid? (I know, magical institutions only exist to help Harry, but never Snape, I get it). Also, nobody checked on Neville when Cousin Algie was trying to kill him. But at this point I think Minerva is ready to skewer Albus herself. |
excessivelyperky chapter 1 . 7/17 Thank you, oh thank you for not reprinting huge portions of the book. But this is rather fun, because even though Dumbledore says he left charms to keep Harry safe, there's no way to confirm any of that. But as it is, Umbridge now knows who a few of the members of the DA are now. |
Leicontis chapter 1 . 7/14 Umbridge's source for the books fits quite nicely with the theory that Hogwarts is at least semi-sentient and really doesn't like her. |
MonsterMaster chapter 12 . 7/10 Ok now i have to read a fiction where Voldemort leaves Harry alone because he's too busy chasing Fred & George because they bullied him during Quirell's year in Hogwarts. |
MonsterMaster chapter 11 . 6/26 Damn that's chapter was so interesting, most of the fics i've read about the characters finding the books were mostly parodies. I love the fact that in your fiction the stakes are very high everything could backfire to Harry, Dumbledore or Fudge. |
Guest chapter 1 . 6/17 Umbridge! The arrogant little b****. |
joshuadavenportherbst chapter 18 . 6/18 Ok, where’s the sequel, I can’t find it |