This was such a beautiful, loving, heartbreaking and hope-giving story. Well done!

What an absolutely fabulous fic! I can totally imagine this being an alternative to what the show did. Thank you so much for writing this!

I loved this so much. SO SO much better than what happened in these episodes. Wish realm overall was a failure and the other Hook and their meeting was disappointing but this is perfect and it would've been so good if something like this happened

Wow! This was beautiful...I really wish we got to see this kind of love between them. Just the soft moments between them. I loved it

This fic was great! I cried like a baby at the end. XD

I read this when you were originally working on it and it was awesome. I decided to go back and read some of my favorites needing CS that's not on the show. And I forgot how awesome this really was. Thanks again for writing an incredible story with the perfect mix of fluff, bittersweet moments, and true love between Emma and whichever Killian is in her life.

I have so much new material to read, but I came across this and had to read it again. It really is beautiful.

Love this beautiful story so much!

Love love love this story! Is there more? Thanks!

For real I think this is the most beautiful thing I ever read. Just thinking of goodbyes makes me cry... this was absolutely amazing. Please never stop writing.

Oh my god! Such a beautiful story with so much love and emotion. I'm literally sobbing right now. How I wished this happened on the show. Instead we got something that made absolutely no sense. As you can tell, I'm a little bitter :).

Beautiful end chapter to a story that truely captures what love is all about.

Oh my EMOTIONS! I am a puddle of feelings! This is so beautiful and different and excruciating and perfect, just perfect. Loved all of this, from the sweet start to the very emotional finish. This was a joy to read, thank you for sharing!

I don't cry often when I read these stories, but I can't help myself. That was beautiful. Their heartache physically hurts me. The power of your words is amazing. Well done. Thank you.

I'm so sad that this was the end of the story, but it was perfect. Old Hook and Emma's goodbye and then current Hook and Emma's reunion was so well written. I had so many tears streaming down my face. The letter and the video that old Hook left for current Hook and Emma was both sentimental and funny. Loved that the white stockings will be a secret between old Hook and Emma, lol. One of the BEST CS stories to date!