Reviews for Athair
slitherinbadgirl1616 chapter 24 . 7/19
I love that Ron was resorted to ravenclaw,I've always thought he could be really smart especially with strategies.
ElysianSamael chapter 25 . 7/16
Please tell me hermione and remus are soulmates it ties in with why he responded to her call - and maybe a possible solution to her curse: the curse prevents her from ever knowing and thus bonding with her soulmate but if her soulmate is already known...

Loving this story in general btw.
Jay chapter 25 . 5/18
This an absolutely enchanting story! I've been nonstop reading and cannot wait for you to update again! This is incredible!
Paradoxpixie chapter 25 . 5/16
Very good work. Unique plot developments! Can’t wait to read more.
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 25 . 5/2
Not 800 years...1,000...

And pleasepleasepleaseplease DON'T pair Harry and Ginny, that's like he's marrying his mother (seriously, she's mostly like a mini-Lily, other than her eye color)! On top of that, she's a fame hound and wants the spotlight while Harry prefers to stay out of it. Someone like Luna, or Hell, Daphne Greengrass or Tracey Davis (now that he's in Slytherin House and can get to know them) would be better options. Virtually anyone but Ginny! And maybe Pansy-I can't see him liking her when she'd remind him of Marge's dog, Ripper...

Otherwise, I'm still liking the story, so please do keep updating!
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 21 . 5/2
Still missing that 800 when it should be 1,000 years...
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 16 . 5/1
Another 800 year reference...
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 14 . 5/1
Salazar wouldn't say 'figure it out'. Or 'work it out'. Possibly 'determine the answer.'

Don't have the Founders call them 'kids' (that's a baby goat). They would call the trio 'children'.
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 6 . 5/1
I don't think the Founders had 'manners' to discuss, I think they had 'matters' to discuss! :D

The Founders wouldn't have called it a 'check-up', they'd have called it a medical examination at worst, or possibly a healer's examination.
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 4 . 5/1
The Founders wouldn't 'work it out', they would 'plan' or 'arrange' it...

A few others I'm not entirely sure about, but I don't think they're worth mentioning without knowing for sure.
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 3 . 5/1
Back to an 800 year gap again, are you?

Godric wouldn't have said 'anytime', he'd have said the more lengthy 'Should you need me at any time...'

Otherwise, I'm not sure 'really' would have been used, but I can't discount it, so this is all for this chapter. Good job.
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 2 . 5/1
Noted that all but first chapter (which still says 800) has been changed to about a 1,000 years...Veritaserum was a recent invention, but it wasn't so recent they had only just invented it, either.

For historical people, you're using 'get' and 'got' too often...They never 'got' anywhere, they 'arrived', and they never 'get' anything, they used whatever term was appropriate...In the case of privacy, probably 'have'. They also wouldn't 'do' anyone, they would use an appropriate term, like in the case of 'testing' the students with legilimency...'get used to' would probably be 'learn to control' the power...

Founders wouldn't 'find a story', they'd 'provide an explanation for the new students' presence'. And yes, you actually need to say that's what the 'story' is for, whether or not you change the wording.

Er...1,000 years ago, they wouldn't know what an adoption agency was...normally family friends would simply take in a child (which, for the record, doesn't fit the three students because the average age of adulthood back then ranged between 12 and 14 years, not 17-18). Though, having one of the not-children 'adopted' would still be logical and would be a good cover.

Why does Salazar need to read Hermione's mind again? He already did that in the first chapter, and also established they aren't threats. He may need another reason to want to read Harry's and Ron's.

One question that occurred to me...why aren't you doing your own research to figure out when things happened based on the HP story line? It's not like that information is hard to find, and the Lexicon is one of the first ones to come up...So in my book...you are the one at fault for ever having had wrong dates, because it wasn't your sister's responsibility to do that for you...
Snow Leopard Pasha chapter 1 . 5/1
Other than the point of your timeline still being wrong (:D), I'm enjoying the story.

To clarify...You can now find on sites like the Harry Potter Lexicon and the Wikia that Hogwarts was officially founded in the year 993AD. So...Unless you are writing this in the 1700's, maybe early 1800's, the passage of time would have been 1,000 years, give or take a bit, not 800.

As for the language use (which you mention at the start of Chapter 2), as long as the Founders and other students from their era aren't using modern slang (like, "You totally did!" or "Go take a hike!", or even just having them call the children 'kids'), you should be fine. I'll note phrases the Founders and those from their time wouldn't know.
lady sesshomaru sama 949 chapter 25 . 4/9
awesome love this hope for more soon!
RedTomato213 chapter 25 . 3/22
Please tell me your gonna continue this story
186 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »