Reviews for The Magic of Deduction
nightshade chapter 34 . 7/14
Aghhh I hope Sirius doesn't go to Sherlock thinking that he'll get to take him from Severus...
And btw, what is Sherlock going to do? Because having spent an entire year trapped in his own mind while his body is lead by who knows what has left his reputation in shatters! I really, really hope that they go to the press with the story of what happened and Albus, Lockheart and Molly face the consequences of their actions. If they don't I don't know what I'll think, since I loved this story and hope to regain that love while finishing the next and last chapter, but fuc*, how have I hated this arc of the story...
I simply wish you luck with your writing and hope you can update soon :3 I can't wait to see what happens next and discover how Sherlock helps Voldemort regain a body!
Ps, hope uni and work are going well! And that you somehow found the lost your thumbdrive, I get how horrible it is to loose such data...
Pss, sorry if the begining of the comment seemed too pessimistic!
nightshade chapter 28 . 7/14
Fuc*, I love your work but good God, this part where Sherlock seems to be turning into Harry is killing me and I hate with my entire heart! I really, really hope that someone can fix his mind soon, because I'm loosing mine...
Corwyn chapter 35 . 7/13
Loving this story so far and hoping there's more. Thanks for sharing it with us.
nightshade chapter 4 . 7/13
Ohhh... I love this story but I'm very disappointed Sherlock didn't get sorted into Ravenclaw and Jon into Hufflepuff... I was imagining every one of them (reincarnated souls) being in different houses and the cahos that would cause *sniff sniff*
Corwyn chapter 24 . 7/12
1 for finding a good reason for the Diary to get to Ginny *despite* Lord Malfoy not being a complete d*ckwad in this story
Corwyn chapter 22 . 7/12
1 for Ophiuchus the serpent-bearer
1 for Wrackspurt silk :-)
era-romance chapter 35 . 7/4
hope u continue this eventually
Tiffany chapter 35 . 7/1
Hi! I saw that youve started on a new fanfic. I was wondering if youre gonna continue this one. I know that youre probably busy, but I really enjoy the story. Ive read through what you have twice now. My friend has also started reading it. Please write more if you're able, and if not just keep up the fantastic writing!
SandyDunes chapter 29 . 7/1
I wept! I heaved a terrible sob! I DIED at chapter 29!

I simply thought Sherlock and gang would be living and making their own history apart from Harry Potter books.
But when your Dumbledore started playing God and manipulating people for no logical reason! I wanted to wring his old wrinkly neck! Why?! Poor Mycroft and John!
To think the one person you care most about, suddenly a shell of who he used to be!
Finding no solution to Sherlock's state. And John! How utterly lost he was, not able to be apart even when he knew Harry wasn't Sherlock...
Just because some slimy codger thought that the world should cater to his ideals and delusions!
Now Sherlock has to make do to what Harry had made while he has been in mental jail. But I'm not too worried about him, he's so brilliant.
I was wailing for the others who watched Harry and suffered Dumbledore's idiocies. Molly just... doesn't even deserve notice. I like to think she doesn't exist.
Seriously, I have a waste bin full of tissues! You did a terrific job at drawing out heartstrings without much cliches.
My God l, this was such a wonderful read! I live for fluff! My heart just COOES at our lovely duo!
I hope John and Sherlock come out alright!
Will definitely reread!
the-cryptid chapter 2 . 6/22
I'm rereading this and just realized you wrote McGongle instead of McGonnagall, idk if someone else has already reviewed and told you
Janina Sotelo chapter 35 . 6/12
please update I am fascinated by that story I read it many times ! I love it ..
Blackmagicbird chapter 35 . 6/12
Ah you haven't update for year! It is very good story! Woah it is morning now welp! I have to go to sleep! But I wish you still update! Be safe!
Blackmagicbird chapter 31 . 6/12
What so relieved! I was very distressed by this wrong personality until Sherlock is back! FINALLY!
thetimechick chapter 35 . 6/5
God! This whole story is fucking brilliant! I LOVE IT.
I absolutely cannot wait for the next chapter! I was tempted to pull my hair out when Sherlock started acting strangeAgitated but relieved, to find out Dumbles had gotten the goblins to bind Sherlock's core. Now I'm nervous, but excited about what Sirius will do next seeing as right now he more than like angry and will do something extreme after hearing that Sherlock has been taken to a place he thinks he doesn't know of. I wonder how will Sherlock react once he's aware that hisUncle Paddy" has broken out of Azkaban and has been dubbed a murderer?
Guest chapter 35 . 6/4
I love and adore the story! Sherlock and Johnald are so freaking cute together! I wish you would pick this one up again! It’s seriously one of the best I have EVER read, and that’s saying quite a lot!
2,138 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »