Awww
I love it! The ending just killed me

Loved it! Nice job. Always fun to see Sam back with Jess but ultimately choosing to be with his brother instead. Thanks for sharing!

The feelings are back

Loved it. Really creative...would make an awesome awesome episode.

Thank you for writing and sharing,

Karen

OMG I loved loved that! What a wonderful story!

Awww poor Sammy. He always has such bad birthdays

I liked that Sam chose to come back...I think that is true to their characters.

So sweet :3 i loved it, you did a fantastic job. Can't wait to see what you write next ;)

Awww, great story :D

This story was really good - I loved it. Thank you.

Awww loved it!.

This was amazing! I loved every second of it and my heart nearly broke when Sam had to let Jess go and again every time one of Dean's parts came on.
Great job, man.

Awe. That was cute. I woke this morning and mind tugged at the date, but I was like "why is May 2 important?" Now I remember.

AAAAUUUUUUGHGGG it's just so cute and I can't take it! I loved this, it was a great little oneshot that satisfied my spn broment cravings for the day lol, keep up the awesome work!

A great idea, nicely done;) definitely enjoyed it and looking forward for more;)